A few weeks ago, @thomaseamoran created a post arguing that the expected value of an Essence Orb was just $1 and that it was not worth the DEC:
https://steemit.com/splinterlands/@thomaseamoran/hot-take-splinterlands-orbs-not-worth-the-dec
As a response, I wanted to take a more statistical look at the issue.
I am going to summarize the conclusions here:
Without potions, the expected value of an Orb is $1.68 - $2.37.
However, around 30% of this expected value comes from getting a Gold Foil (which is 2%).
And more than 50% of this expected value comes from getting an Epic or Legendary (which is 4.8%)
Depending on how you buy your Orbs they can cost from $1.71 - $2.50 and you are getting $1.68 - $2.37 in expected value.
Using both Brilliant potions, the expected value of an Orb is $2.59 - $3.83.
However, as much as 50% of this expected value comes from getting a Gold Foil (which is around 4%)
And as much as 66% of this expected value comes from getting an Epic or Legendary (which is 5.6%)
Using both potions (which costs 90 DEC without guild discounts) increases the expected value of a card by 54% - 62%, which definitely makes the potions net positive in DEC value.
(The cost of each Orb includes pro rata costs for the potion charges).
Depending on how you buy your Orbs they can cost from $2.04 - $2.95 using potions and you are getting $2.59 - $3.83 in expected value.
If you want to look at the numbers, data, and math, you can continue reading below.
We know that the Card Drop Rates for Reward Cards are:
75.2% - Common
20% - Rare
4% - Epic
0.8% - Legendary
And the chance for a card being Gold Foil is 2% (so a 98% chance of it being Regular).
At the very end of this article I will discuss the Card Drop Rates for Boosters and Orbs which guarantee at least one card of Rare or better.
I created a Google Sheet with the calculations:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1C3tyrN8OKYlURGHR-Cbm9M60VT-fVycvFxXvi6FTToE/edit?usp=sharing
Feel free to Make a Copy and tweak the values of the cards to see how it affects the Expected Value of the Orb. Using Peakmonsters, I took the data based on the lowest single price on the market as well as the highest bid that you could instantly fulfill. This data will constantly change due to market dynamics.
We can see that the Expected Value of one card =
% chance of Regular * (Probability of Regular Common * Average Value of Regular Common + Probability of Regular Rare * Average Value of Regular Rare + Probability of Regular Epic * Average Value of Regular Epic + Probability of Regular Legendary * Average Value of Regular Legendary)
PLUS
% chance of Gold * (Probability of Gold Common * Average Value of Gold Common + Probability of Gold Rare * Average Value of Gold Rare + Probability of Gold Epic * Average Value of Gold Epic + Probability of Gold Legendary * Average Value of Gold Legendary)
Let’s start by analyzing the High Bid value without any Potions:
0.98 * (0.752 * $0.097 + 0.2 * $0.169 + 0.04 * $1.950 + 0.008 * $6.987) +
0.02 * (0.752 * $1.938 + 0.2 * $5.504 + 0.04 * $26.625 + 0.008 * $128)
= $0.3288 for one card, which is roughly $1.64 for one Orb
Of the $0.3288 expected value:
$0.2358 (72%) comes from a Regular card
$0.0929 (28%) comes from the small chance of getting a Gold Foil
If we instead look along rarity lines:
$0.1006 (31%) comes from getting a Common card
$0.0551 (17%) comes from getting a Rare
$0.0977 (30%) comes from getting an Epic, and
$0.0753 (23%) comes from getting a Legendary
So the majority of the expected value comes from getting an Epic or Legendary, even though 95.2% of the time you will just get a Common or Rare.
If we instead look at the Low Buy value without any Potions we have:
0.98 * (0.752 * $0.124 + 0.2 * $0.219 + 0.04 * $3.050 + 0.008 * $8.823) +
0.02 * (0.752 * $2.643 + 0.2 * $6.317 + 0.04 * $41.385 + 0.008 * $280)
= $0.4660 for one card, which is roughly $2.33 for one Orb
Of the $0.4660 expected value:
$0.323 (69%) comes from a Regular card
$0.1429 (31%) comes from the small chance of getting a Gold Foil
If we instead look along rarity lines:
$0.1311 (28%) comes from getting a Common card
$0.068 (15%) comes from getting a Rare
$0.1527 (33%) comes from getting an Epic, and
$0.114 (24%) comes from getting a Legendary
Once again, the majority of the expected value comes from getting an Epic or Legendary.
Now let’s look at the numbers when we add in both Brilliant (+100%) Legendary and Brilliant (+100%) Alchemy Potions.
I’m assuming that when you use a Legendary Potion to increase the chance for a Legendary, that the increased chance results in an equal decreased chance of a Common card.
For High Bid with Potions:
0.96 * (0.744 * $0.097 + 0.2 * $0.169 + 0.04 * $1.950 + 0.016 * $6.987) +
0.04 * (0.744 * $1.938 + 0.2 * $5.504 + 0.04 * $26.625 + 0.016 * $128)
= $0.5102 for one card, which is roughly $2.04 for one Orb
Of the $0.5102 expected value:
$0.2839 (56%) comes from a Regular card
$0.2262 (44%) comes from the small chance of getting a Gold Foil
If we instead look along rarity lines:
$0.1270 (25%) comes from getting a Common card
$0.0765 (15%) comes from getting a Rare
$0.1175 (23%) comes from getting an Epic, and
$0.1892 (37%) comes from getting a Legendary
Using the Potions resulted in a 0.5102 / 0.3288 = 1.55 --> 55% increase in value
Not factoring in the Guild discount, a Brilliant Legendary Potion costs 20,000 DEC for 500 charges while a Brilliant Alchemy Potion costs 25,000 DEC for 500 charges (which is enough for 100 boosters or orbs). That means you are spending 90 DEC for each card flipped to increase the value by 55%. Several guilds right now have a 3%-5% discount so that would actually be 87.3 and 85.5 DEC respectively. Once you reach the maximum 10% discount it will just be 81 DEC per card.
Finally, we will look at Low Buy with Potions:
0.96 * (0.744 * $0.124 + 0.2 * $0.219 + 0.04 * $3.050 + 0.016 * $8.823) +
0.04 * (0.744 * $2.643 + 0.2 * $6.317 + 0.04 * $41.385 + 0.016 * $280)
= $0.7579 for one card, which is roughly $3.80 for one Orb
Of the $0.7579 expected value:
$0.3833 (51%) comes from a Regular card
$0.3746 (49%) comes from the small chance of getting a Gold Foil
If we instead look along rarity lines:
$0.1672 (22%) comes from getting a Common card
$0.0926 (12%) comes from getting a Rare
$0.1833 (24%) comes from getting an Epic, and
$0.3147 (42%) comes from getting a Legendary
Now, half the expected value comes from getting a Gold Foil. And 42% of the expected value comes from getting a Legendary. This makes sense since Gold Foil Legendaries command a premium when you look at Low Buy prices.
Using the Potions resulted in a 0.7579 / 0.4660 = 1.63 --> 63% increase in value for using the 90 DEC (per card) charges.
Since each Orb costs 2500 DEC (without discounts), a card should be worth 500 DEC. Increasing its expected value by 55%-63% for the cost of 90 DEC is definitely worth it.
If you did a bulk Orb purchase (buying 100 at a time to get 10 bonus Orbs) and you used a 10% guild discount, then the average cost of each Orb would be: 250,000 DEC * 0.9 / 110 = 2046 DEC. If you had the 10% discount using the potions would cost 81 DEC per card, which is still worth it for the 55%-63% increase in expected value.
One final note. In our calculations we looked at each card individually and then multiplied that by five to get the expected value of an Orb. The average value of an Orb (which contains 5 cards) will actually be slightly higher because of the guarantee that at least one card will be Rare or better so you wouldn’t have the scenario where you end up with 5 commons.
@tcpolymath gave me some of @cryptoeater 's numbers. The adjusted drop rate for boosters and Orbs taking into account the "one card rare or better" guarantee is:
Orb Drop Rate without any Potions
Regular Common: 0.689825
Regular Rare: 0.243135
Regular Epic: 0.0392
Regular Legendary: 0.00784
Gold Common: 0.014078
Gold Rare: 0.004961
Gold Epic: 0.0008
Gold Legendary: 0.00016
Substituting these values in the above equations we get:
High Bid value without any Potions:
(0.689825 * $0.097 + 0.243135 * $0.169 + 0.0392 * $1.950 + 0.00784 * $6.987) +
(0.014078 * $1.938 + 0.004961 * $5.504 + 0.0008 * $26.625 + 0.00016 * $128)
= $0.3356 for one card, which is roughly $1.68 for one Orb
Low Buy value without any Potions:
(0.689825 * $0.124 + 0.243135 * $0.219 + 0.0392 * $3.050 + 0.00784 * $8.823) +
(0.014078 * $2.643 + 0.004961 * $6.317 + 0.0008 * $41.385 + 0.00016 * $280)
= $0.4740 for one card, which is roughly $2.37 for one Orb
Orb Drop Rate with Potions
Regular Common: 0.6680669388
Regular Rare: 0.2381730612
Regular Epic: 0.0384
Regular Legendary: 0.01536
Gold Common: 0.026878
Gold Rare: 0.009922
Gold Epic: 0.0016
Gold Legendary: 0.00064
High Bid value with Potions:
(0.6680669388 * $0.097 + 0.2381730612 * $0.169 + 0.0384 * $1.950 + 0.01536 * $6.987) +
(0.026878 * $1.938 + 0.009922 * $5.504 + 0.0016 * $26.625 + 0.00064 * $128)
= $0.5185 for one card, which is roughly $2.59 for one Orb
This is a 54% increase in value using potions.
Low Buy value with Potions:
(0.6680669388 * $0.124 + 0.2381730612 * $0.219 + 0.0384 * $3.050 + 0.01536 * $8.823) +
(0.026878 * $2.643 + 0.009922 * $6.317 + 0.0016 * $41.385 + 0.00064 * $280)
= $0.7668 for one card, which is roughly $3.83 for one Orb
This is a 62% increase in value using potions.
Feel free to provide feedback and definitely let me know if I made any mistakes in my calculations.
Great deep dive into the numbers. There's always more to learn. Love it :)
I always thought you were a hard opponent and when I see the amount of detail you have put into this, I am sure you also have formulas for matches and caps too. Nice work😉
Great review on orbs.
I am more interested in what happens to the price when they sell out . Also I have not looked into it but I know not everyone is looking at orbs so a small portion of the community of Splinterlands could end up with all the orb cards . This could potentially make them more valuable.
There are a lot of factors that can drive up demand on cards .
One factor not to be overlooked is those wanting to own one of every card .
I know you can not really add these factors in but they do play a part.
That’s just my opinion ,
Have an awesome day!
Posted using Partiko iOS
FYI: I got some helpful feedback from @tcpolymath that the Card Drop percentages I was using is for Reward cards and that there actually are adjusted percentages for boosters and Orbs that take into account the "at least one Rare or better card" guarantee. He gave me some additional probabilities that were calculated by @cryptoeater so I'll be incorporating that to calculate some slightly more accurate numbers.
So many numbers... my head is spinning... ;0)
Great analysis buddy. Not much of a math guy, this kind of topic makes my head spin lol
This is a whole lot of math, that is quite amazing you took your time to do it.
Interesting to see the average rewards I get from an orb.
Congratulations @byzantinist! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOPVote for @Steemitboard as a witness to get one more award and increased upvotes!
So maybe it is better to wait and buy at least 1 orb plus 1 potion to increase chance of gettin at least one foil card.
I can't argue with your math, I'm an English teacher :). While I don't buy orbs and just rely on getting them in chests (so my sample size is really small - 20-30 total orbs), I can say, anecdotally, that my normal return is well under $1 per orb. I pulled 1 legendary card total (minotaur warlord) and 3 GF (just got one today, actually). But even when I pull a GF, the total value of that orb is still under $2. The vast majority of my orbs have 4 common and the 1 guaranteed rare card valued around 40 cents total. That's with both potions going on all of those orbs (I only have the potions activated for packs and orbs). I'm sure I just need a larger sample size...or better luck. I opened 180+ Untamed packs and pulled ZERO legendary cards. My average value of each pack was well under $1, too :/