Personally I don't like this thing that everyone wants to force on steemit - we are all equal - let's be honest - we are not. And as far as I am concerned there shouldn't be any reports for the sake of reports - and showing what people have done right, they probably know it and other people probably won't even read it.
More about curation - I think it is good as it is (about transparency) we see "who voted" and what percent - that is just fine and lets be honest curators must be objective but with more transparency and reports there will be more subjectivity to it and making it a lot harder for them. What curators could do is actually start a discussion in comment section - which will add more value to comments and be an example to others (doesn't have to be a must; but rather if they find it good post or want to know a bit more about something in it).
Now speaking of comments - it is a great idea! Practice shows that with more comments and engagement more material is produced - especially if it is encouraged by other users - and making a post about something discussed in the comment section is just amazing. Comment voting is a must - doesn't need to be a greart percent - but maybe 10-20/0 is just enough or something similar.
P.S. I must start using steemstem.io - it is so easy to find posts with it and it is great for reading but somehow when I post I do it on steemit : / must change that activity.
Lets keep rocking this chain! :)
The point is not to write reports for writing reports, but mainly to answer a demand from the community. People are confused about the choice of the voting strengths and we want to fill this gap. As this requires more work from the curators, we propose to incentive them with a report-upvote. On the other hand, having reports being an open door to discussions is a good idea.
I still need to improve this but time is limited... ;)
just to clarify this. We propose the vote, for example, 20/20 or 65/65. Another curator than confirms the value and vote. So if you have seen that I've "executed" the vote it doesn't mean that I've made the decision by my own will
This is a good idea, and I often do this if... I know what's going on in that particular post. For "space stuff" I'm completely blunt :(
I agree with you, some content sucks. Doesn't matter if you worked hard on it, if it's bad it's bad. I could spend days painting something, and I guarantee you it would suck. :)