Yes ;-) I think both. In fact maybe I don't really like a stamp at all. However, I guess it is required. The animation isn't too bad, but the colors are worse. I guess my ideal would be a circular-ish animation with a transparent background, the colors of the animation itself are maybe not so important, but a big-ish (many others are much bigger than your first one) square with a very bright color and animation doesn't fall well on my eyes.
But it is a very good first, you can settle for it now. Not super big, and not super screamy.
Ok thanks for your extensive explanation. I will definitely take these into account as I work on my next iteration!