This just triggered me too, gave me some PTSD from something that happened a few weeks ago...
I sold my Magic the Gathering cards a few weeks ago to the most well known magic the gathering website in my country, which I've done business previously, he sent them back after 1 day and sent me an email that they were damaged, well, the deck is in perfect shape, I've shown people that the cards are in perfect shape, I've only used the deck once in my life!!
I sent him an email, he never got back to me...
Well, at least the sent the cards back, your situation is worse since you were basically robbed.
I hope you get your money back
Ugh. You are giving me goosebumps as we are about to get into selling a ton of expensive MTG cards on consignment for a gentleman. Hope it goes smoother than your experience. Lol
Posted using Partiko iOS