Congratulations, and good thinking on crowd sourcing your name decision. It's a tough one! My wife and I recently had our first. We didn't know whether it would be a boy or girl, and hadn't settled on a boy name we could agree on, so we were lucky to have a girl.
We had a "Z" theme going with our names. Our little girl is Zoe Heather. My wife did not like my biblical "Z" name, Zerubbabel. Maybe you can use it---Zerubabbel John.