Curation Rewards - Various Proposed Policies - Fixed Poll

in #dpoll6 years ago

Curation Rewards - Various Proposed Policies - Fixed Poll


Which of the following options for curation rewards are preferable to the status quo? Select the options that are better than no change.

The status quo is 75% of post rewards going to authors, 25% going to curators, with a superlinear distribution of curation rewards (in other words, you get more for voting on posts that other people vote for later).

Here are the proposed changes:

A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators. This is being proposed by @kevinwong and several others.

B. Curation reward slider on post creation. Author decides the split of author and curation rewards on their post.

C. Flat curation rewards. When you upvote a post, you get a portion of that vote as a reward. Curators do not earn by predicting others, but there is no opportunity cost in curation rewards for upvoting something that already has votes. Described by @miniature-tiger here

D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote. Also described here by @miniature-tiger. The voter can decide how much of their vote goes to the author, and how much goes to themselves on payout.

E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation. A combination of options B and C


  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.

  • B. Curation reward slider on post creation.

  • C. Flat curation rewards.

  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.

  • E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation.

  • None of the options are preferable to status quo. Prefer no change.

Answer the question at dpoll.xyz.

Sort:  

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.
  • C. Flat curation rewards.
  • E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation.

Voted for

  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.
  • E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation.

Voted for

  • B. Curation reward slider on post creation.
  • C. Flat curation rewards.
  • E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation.

Voted for

  • None of the options are preferable to status quo. Prefer no change.

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.
  • C. Flat curation rewards.
  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.

We need to improve the reward policy to be ready for mass adoption of new users.

Voted for

  • None of the options are preferable to status quo. Prefer no change.

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.

Voted for

  • C. Flat curation rewards.
  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.

Taking out the guessing of future votes sounds like a step in the direction of more manual curation

Thanks for contributing to the dPoll content.

You have been upvoted from our community curation account (@dpoll.curation) in courtesy of This Guy... @bluerobo.

Come, join our community at dPoll discord server.


If you want to support dPoll curation, you can also delegate some steem power. Quick steem connect links to delegate:
50SP | 100SP | 250SP | 500SP

Voted for

  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.

Voted for

  • C. Flat curation rewards.

Voted for

  • C. Flat curation rewards.

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.
  • B. Curation reward slider on post creation.
  • C. Flat curation rewards.
  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.
  • E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation.

Given them all a vote although I'm not sure any changes will happen, at least not for the main token. Something for SMT to tackle perhaps?

Voted for

  • E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation.

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.
  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.
  • E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation.

Voted for

  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.

Voted for

  • None of the options are preferable to status quo. Prefer no change.

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.
  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.

Voted for

  • B. Curation reward slider on post creation.

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.

Voted for

  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.

Voted for

  • B. Curation reward slider on post creation.
  • D. Flat curation rewards + curation reward slider per vote.
  • E. Flat curation rewards with slider on post creation.

I think giving users, both authors and creators, the choice of being able to choose how much of the reward goes to one party over the other is the best solution. I am most supportive of a curation reward slider for authors as that would really give the best choice with the greatest amount of simplicity. I am most doubtful about having it be where voters choose the reward amount as that sorta conflicts with the slider we already use for voting power percentage. Also, I worry that would make the whole process too complicated. That being said though, any of the choices where the choice of the user is involved I would support.

I refuse to support the idea of a 50/50 split. I also don't believe that just plain fiat currency rewards are all that great, though I think it would be better than the 50/50 split. Quite frankly, I would take the current status quo over a 50/50 split. This is because, quite frankly, there are more important things the Steem network needs to be concerned with than reward ratios! (SMT's anyone?)

Voted for

  • A. 50/50 reward split between authors and curators.
  • B. Curation reward slider on post creation.