You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: A Discussion of the Role of Government in Entrepreneurship

After reading your essay, I thought you did an excellent job at giving a very well-thought-out analysis of the views that Bastiat had expressed in his collection of writings. You made sure to highlight a few of his perspectives when it came to the involvement of the government in entrepreneurship. You also included relevant examples and anecdotes to support your views and make the essay more interesting to read. Overall, I think you offered a thorough assessment of Bastiat's opinions as well as a discussion on their significance and relevance to current times. Your article exhibited a thorough comprehension of Bastiat's writings.

This cynical view of the government can be applied in some circumstances, but it does not encompass the full scope of the government.
I totally agree with you on this statement. While Bastiat's ideas were thought-provoking and intelligent, they were not without limits. As a result, while his views may still be relevant today, they should not be accepted as the absolute truth and should be critically analyzed in regard to current events and situations. It is critical to recognize that the function of the government is multidimensional and complicated, and a one-dimensional view of it would be insufficient.

When it came down to you explaining Bastiat's views on government control of supply through the use of a satirical petition of the French government from manufacturers of "everything connected with lighting." You also showed and provided a very balanced perspective, acknowledging that the government's involvement in entrepreneurship is undeniable but debatable in terms of its benefits. I understand your point of view on Bastiat's conception of government as an organization designed to help individuals, which is not entirely true.

In your 'The Motivating Forces of Man' section you provided an overview of Bastiat's Frédéric’s views on laws and how they apply to modern times. you
also managed to support your view on the topics, adding credibility to your argument.

Overall, your article presents a well-argued and balanced viewpoint on the beliefs expressed by Frédéric Bastiat. Your essay effortlessly conveys the essential elements of Bastiat's writings and offers a critical critique of his points of view. The essay is well-written, using simple language and a solid conclusion. Your essay also provides a balanced perspective, acknowledging that while the modern legal system is not perfect, it allows each individual to have a say in the governance of society.