RE: Ethics Are What The Majority Invent in Order to Keep Themselves Enslaved

[fingersik]

I never said it is a fact...it clearly is just my opinion...and the very same can be said about your "definition".

Comments

[ocrdu]

I defined nothing, and most certainly not for others.

It is not "just your opinion", as your statement derives straight from an economical and societal theory other people came up with, yet is stated as fact. Don't you get you are making his point for him?

[fingersik]

I don’t get what you’re trying to accomplish here...he said that in order for the author to be consistent he has to find holocaust ok...that is completely invalid...

It is not "just your opinion", as your statement derives straight from an economical and societal theory other people came up with

What if I had that opinion even prior finding out about libertarianism? Is it still not just my opinion (the fact that some others share doesn’t make it “not just my opinion”? I don’t care what others think about it or if there is any movement that shares the point of view that I reached by my own conclusions...Nothing like purely new thought exists...Every opinion is based on what other people came up with...

I, for instance, see such force being used in moral terms, and not in terms of rights-as-defined-in-some-theory.

You defined this for yourself (I never said you defined it for someone else...why are you defending yourself against something i never said? I defined what I said for myself and i shared my point of view the same way you have shared yours...i did not force my opinion onto anyone and i was interested what he will say about it yet you step in with your blame that what I said is not a fact - I never claimed it to be one.

With what I said i think I refuted his statement that

...you don't have any grounds on which to criticize any action as "unjust".

This is how discussion are held. People exchange their opinions. What is the aim of your intervention kind sir? If it was an effort of showing me that I am making his points for him then you certainly are not correct...so either explain yourself and discuss with me correctly or just stop wasting my time:)