Well thought out & well written. I agree with this is it's entirety. Especially the basis- that a TRANS-WOMAN- can Never Truly now what is means or feels like to be a REAL WOMAN.
The only item I would point out is-
One cannot prove scientifically the existence of an innate sense of self that contradicts the reality of nature.
That is true. It is also why one can not Scientifically prove in the existence of many things- one of them being a Higher Power- a Higher Guiding Force Guiding all life & the Universe- or what others call God.
Although a case can be made for why or how or the FACTORS that led many Trans-Woman to that- such as Child-hood Brainwashing, Childhood Abuse, The mother being exposed to certain chemicals or the mother's body being flooded with certain hormones while the baby was in the fetus- and that a Trans-Individual body& brain may be full of certain chemicals & hormones that don't belong there & have this extreme effect on them- There are many reasons-
But one reason that could never be Scientifically Proven- would be is Esoteric or Metaphysical- if in fact somehow a "FEMALE SPIRIT or Female Soul- actually was Incarnated into a Male Fetus.
I understand this Esoteric question is a TANGENT Off The Main issues of this TRANSGENDER AGENDA & is not relevant in the case of many Transgender Individuals- Nor does this Esoteric Tangent- Contradict any of your arguments & line of reasoning in this post.
As another sidenote- I have in real life spent more than a little time around a number of Transgender Women. Most of the ones I met did put on a "HYPER-SEXUAL" Female display.