Capitalism: Greed vs Giving
Introduction
Capitalism is a system founded on exchange which allows entrepreneurs to flourish and competition to drive the economy forward. We have seen before that a capitalist society is never stationary and that new innovations are constantly making old ones obsolete through creative destruction. What if the exchange was not purely economic, purely business? What if entrepreneurs instead took a page out of the playbook of indigenous people and considered the needs of those around them and gave a gift of some value with the understanding that they would receive one of greater value at a later date? George Gilder proposed an idea of capitalism that conflicts with that of Adam Smith’s. He believes that gift giving is the founding tenet of capitalism and that fulfilling the needs of those around is the way to personal gain. Of course, in a modern capitalist society, the mechanism of gift giving is not the same as an indigenous tribe hundreds of years ago. In today’s society, gift giving is akin to investing. You pour resources into another in an attempt to help them thrive and with the goal of potentially getting your investment and more in the backend. This altruism is a key to economic growth in modern society.
Giving as the Driving Force of Capitalism
Giving is something that brings a lot of people happiness. Forgoing your own selfish desires to fulfill the needs of someone else feels inherently good. Potlatching is a practice of indigenous people where you give a gift, forgoing your selfish desires for a period, but with the expectation of getting a gift of more value in the future (p. 28, 2012). This appears to be self-motivated but if everyone is acting in their own self interest to serve others, is that necessarily a bad thing? As long as the cycle of gift giving continues, everyone seems to be better off. In chapter three of his essay, Wealth and Poverty, Gilder states:
“Not taking and consuming, but giving, risking, and creating are the characteristic roles of the capitalist, the key producer of the wealth of nations, from the least developed to the most advanced” (p. 27, 2012).
The reason that giving is the driving force of capitalism, in a lot of cases, is because of the attention to detail and the forethought it requires to give a gift that truly satisfies the need of that who you are giving it to. If it were not for this consideration of one’s wants and desires, the whole purpose of gift giving to one day receive a reciprocal gift of your own would crumble. To eventually get something that represents value to you, you must first go out and decide what you can give that represents value to someone else. Gilder even discusses how the best gifts fulfill a need or desire that the recipient is not even consciously aware they have (p. 32, 2012). It takes a lot of sympathy to diagnose one’s needs from afar and then remedy those needs with the perfect gesture. This is a romantic view of how a capitalist society creates economic growth. If only this were an absolute but unfortunately not all entrepreneurs are acting in this manner at all times.
Greed as the Driving Force of Capitalism
Capitalism is based on competition, and because of that often times entrepreneurs are focused more on what their competition is doing, rather than what their customers want. This drive to crush the competition for self-gain is hard to ignore because it can feel like it is you versus the world. When making money becomes the primary goal of the operation, it can have lots of negative ramifications on the product. First of all, entrepreneurs who are concerned about profit can cut corners, leaving the consumer with a lower quality product. This is not bettering society in the way that free transactions are designed to do. These entrepreneurs will also be looking to deceive the consumer in whatever manner possible to keep them happy and turn a profit. This does not mean, however, that greedy entrepreneurs cannot be successful entrepreneurs. If they are continuing to innovate to stay ahead of the competition, the customer is reaping the rewards. I would imagine that it is more difficult to come up with solutions to problems that consumers do not even know they have when you are too busy looking over your shoulder at what the competition is doing though. I think the vast majority of entrepreneurs are on a spectrum of greed to giving. There are very little absolutes in life and I think depending on the context or the scenario, anyone could find themselves being greedy or altruistic on any given day.
References
Gilder, G. F. (2012). Chapter Three: The Returns of Giving. In Wealth and poverty (pp. 27–49). essay, Regnery Publishing, Inc.
I thought you did a very good job with explaining what Gilder was trying to say in his article about greed and how it can hurt in many ways. I also thought it was very well laid out with a very good understanding and explanation of the reading. It was very easy to read and made a lot of very good points, all pointing back to your main overall topic.
I thought that this was a very good point to bring up and I felt that this highlighted your main point very well in your article. It is very hard to be selfish when trying to grow into a successful venture, and you often have to make sacrifices. Many entrepreneurs invest lots of their own money in order to ensure that there venture is successful, which makes it even sweeter as you see the venture begin to succeed in the field.
I also really liked your comments on greed and how entrepreneurs often focus on their competition more than what the consumers want. I think this is a real problem and can end up hurting their ventures more and more every day. When making money is the only goal, it can lead to poor quality of work, and that can hurt your business as well. Of doubt, there are instances of businesses operating egotistically and disregarding the interests and wants of customers under a capitalist society. Maintaining quality as your business grows is something that every growing business must deal with, and can be very hard to do. It is one of the many problems you face as your company grows more, but is very important to ensure that you maintain your reputation. Reputation is so very big in any field that you choose to get in to, with social media for example, it can be a very big task maintaining a good reputation for your business.
Overall, I felt this was a very well thought out article, and it did a very good job of explaining and staying on topic. It was very easy to read and follow along with to stay engaged as the reader.
As you mentioned in your Greed as the Driving Force of Capitalism paragraph, the ultimate determinant of capitalism is competition and self-desire. In this market structure, entrepreneurs and businesspeople are driven by their ability to collect their treasure based on their own success. You made an interesting point highlighting the physical and negative mental effects this may have on individuals and society. Later, you mentioned,
While I agree with your viewpoint, putting an entrepreneur’s complete focus on business profits is an unwise approach, I do not believe this will cause the individual to cut corners. A capitalist mindset will cause a CEO to make the most cost-efficient, productive decision for their company. In most cases, this will not allow for corners to be cut. This is because while businesses may test cheaper alternatives, ultimately the consumer dictates the market. More times than not, consumers look for higher quality products which require higher quality production.
However, on the other hand, I do agree that these masterminds are willing to manipulate their customer base for their own financial benefit. These high-level businesspeople deeply study their audience. As a result, they play different business and marketing schemes to trick their customers. Oftentimes, once they begin to see success in this approach, they believe they understand their customer base more than anyone else. This can cause them to continuously cut corners and make selfish decisions that may lead to their own demise. Thus, why I agree with your overall message, their obsession with wealth can simultaneously stand as their biggest advantage and disadvantage. As you mentioned, greedy entrepreneurs are more than capable of becoming successful. Oftentimes it is this same infatuation with success that has landed them in their place of power.
Despite this greed, the true outline of capitalism comes in providing gifts through exchange. Through tradeoffs, we supply one another with different items that satisfy both sides. If both parties feel they equally benefited from the barter, they will continue to do so. This continuously swapping across all platforms is what boosts the economy. Therefore, under capitalism, if all entrepreneurs and consumers adopt this frame of mind, the economy will flourish, and everyone will be happy.
Congratulations @carsonrainbolt! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain And have been rewarded with New badge(s)
Your next target is to reach 50 replies.
You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOPCheck out our last posts:
Support the HiveBuzz project. Vote for our proposal!