*The critical posts that I would do on HIVE publications are only here to improve and evolve this wonderful system
Hive Comments and debates
Today I will focus my speech on the comments of the posts:
Following each article, there is a reply area where it is possible to argue your vote, comment or debate on the publications
After many readings I noticed:
- The gradual loss of human intervention:
Many bots and trail systems vote automatically and some of them sometimes leave comments out of context.
For example, following a very sad (and dramatic) post, with hardly any comments, a bot post and congratulated the author for having won a certain bonus !!!
- The loss of critical or reflexive dimension:
This week, an article written in several languages raised several dimensions of recent news: - Mafia and corruption;
- Politicization, political and commercial strategy to encourage emigration;
- Economic dimension;
- Human trafficking;
- Trafficking in goods and smuggled ....
And in the comments no debate was raised on the important points.
In my opinion it is important and essential to encourage more members of the hive community to engage, not only in the publications but also in the readings and comments.
Alerte sur des points négatifs de hive - Commentaires et débats #1
Les articles critiques que je ferais sur les publications de HIVE ne sont ici que pour améliorer et faire évoluer ce manifique système
Les commentaires et les débats :
Aujourdh'ui je focilserai mon discours sur les commentaires des publications:
A suite de chaque article, il existe une zone de réponse où il est possible d'argumenter son vote, de commenter ou de débatre sur la publications
A la suite nombreuses lectures j'ai pu remarquer:
- La perte progressive de l'intervention humaine: De nombreux robots et des systèmes de trail, vote autmatiquement et certains d'entre eux laissent parfois des commentaires hors contexte.
Par exemple, suite à un article très triste (et dramatique), avec pratiquement pas de commentaires, un robot est passé et il a félicité l'auteur pour avoir gagner un certain bonus !!!
- La perte de dimension critique ou reflexive: Cette semaine, un article écrit en plusieurs langues a soulevé plusieurs dimensions d'actualités récentes:
- Mafia et corruption;
- Politisation, startégie politique et commerciale d'incitation à l'émigration;
- Dimension économique;
- Trafic humain;
- Trafic de marchandise et contrebandes d'état ....
Et dans les commentaires aucun débats n'a été soulevé sur les points importants.
A mon avis il est important et primordial d'inciter plus les membres des communauté de hive à l'engagement, non seulement dans les publications mais aussi dans les lectures et les commentaires.
Image source
Challenge: #IAmAliveChallenge
Congratulations @mondhero! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
Your next target is to reach 300 upvotes.
You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOPCheck out the last post from @hivebuzz:
This is a debate that has been going on for years. So many people have tried to find ways to encourage commenting, but in the end it's down to each individual as to whether they choose to or not. Then those who comment also have to find your post. It can take time to build up a following of people who have similar interests to start these conversations. Then there is the other side of the equation where people write a post and never respond to the comments or debate they receive, which puts people off trying to comment.
You can only do what you think is the right approach, see who responds and try to encourage whey you like. You can't force others to do what they aren't inclined to do.
Like in the real life , you can do what seems fair to you , but you cannot force people to do the same.
"Montrer l'exemple n'est pas la meilleure façon d'influencer les gens, c'est la seule"
I think that way under ten percent of the "users" who vote on my posts have actually read the posts. It's a shame really, as I think most of my posts offer value. I do however appreciate the people who vote for doing so. An algorithm to vastly reduce the amount of the voters reward unless a meaningful comment is made (with another algorithm to rate the meaningfulness of the comment) could really shake things up on Hive :-) With an equitable community governance system with a concentrated consensus mechanism such as The Matrix-8 Solution could help bring this into being. Namaste
Yay! 🤗
Your content has been boosted with Ecency Points, by @hiveboost.
Use Ecency daily to boost your growth on platform!
Support Ecency
Vote for Proposal
Delegate HP and earn more