You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Hive is socialist

in Deep Dives4 years ago

I don't know, I wouldn't take Catalonia for a successful cause ... Spain still takes them for its own, all leaders have been severely punished ... hey, in Europe, people are imprisoned for political crimes because they think differently or want something independence ...
Yugoslavia ... but I'm from exYU, I wouldn't agree that nationalism was the cause of the catastrophe that happened later, Yu was totally credited and the catastrophe happened when the loans had to be repaid ... and then everyone else was to blame ...
Syria? Um ... with the dictator from before, because everything went well until the drought and the endangered Syrian tribes moved to the area controlled by this dictator and the solution was that they later went to Europe, and next to them they had millions of more Pakistanis, Afghanis, Bangladesh and I don't know who else ... they caused total global chaos ... ... you didn't exactly convince me 😎

Sort:  

In a libertarian socialist society, there are no leaders as it functions as either a direct democracy or a liquid democracy. Like I said, they were destroyed by fascists around the start of WW2 (1939) and after that they became part of Spain again.

Also, Yugoslavia was not a libertarian socialist system, that may not have been clear in my post. It was a federal republic, not unlike the USA, Nepal, or Germany. That puts it as being more authoritarian than libertarian, though nowhere close to the degree of the USSR.

While the rise of nationalism in Yugoslavia was in part driven by the economic crisis, things could've gone a different way had there not been a rise in nationalism. A good chunk of the Yugoslav Wars was driven by nationalism.

In 1989, Yugoslavia had an external debt of USD$17B, or about 19.2% of its GNP.

For comparison, today, the USA has an external debt of USD$21.3T, or about 98.8% of its 2019 GNP (roughly ~140% of its 2020 GNP due to the pandemic). Debt isn't the only factor, else the USA would be a wasteland right now.

Syria and the NES are different governances entirely, given the region's ongoing civil war that should've been more clear. The NES has a population of around 2 million and is currently not recognised by any major government. They currently have 23 represented political parties and operate under a federated semi-direct democracy, with a goal of moving as close to direct democracy as possible over time.