No one said anything about human worth or human character? If Mav title was about any of those things, then there wouldn't need to be Mav Status... Everyone would get it when we earned it through our character.
Maybe it will ease your concerns to remember that the SPL Discord status is not in DAO's control - Mav status was a benefit that Splinterlands promised, and I suspect that they won't want to break that promise. I support that, honestly. However if the community votes that SPS holders want a change like this, it will certainly send a message that something needs to change.
But comparing the current price of 100,000 SPS to the full price of 1000 brand new packs is a bait-and-switch... millions of packs were bought with cheap DEC, often with bulk purchase discounts, and came with free airdrops and other promos, and many were resold or churned for profit. Meanwhile, other people bought SPS at prices many multiples higher than they are now. So comparing the current price of SPS to your sticker price of packs is not really objective.
Right now, the company says that player feedback is valued only if you buy one type of asset - Packs. So everything else: Spellbooks, referrals, Land, Splinterfest tickets, building guilds, buying promo cards, supporting other games, participating in the economy - these are all lesser activities and those voices don't matter?
SPS is the governance token. It is literally, the One Ring to Rule Them All. I get that people made decisions on the Buy Packs model. But if they were designing Mav Status today, I would bet they would prioritize SPS stake to support the flywheel.
but read the proposal correctly. he thinks he would prevent salt and trolling. this implies that i, who bought 1000 packs in the store instead of 2000 packs on the market. am potentially a bigger danger to troll and spread salt than someone who owns 100k sps and that's why he wants to take away my mav title.
so he measures the value (the characteristic of a character) of a person by his sps. i mean alone that he calls people trolls who have invested thousands of dollars in the game. you can tell with which disturbed person he wrote this proposal. with the person who should have been banned from the discord long ago according to the community rules.
Yeah, I kind of agree, I am not really sure if his proposal actually prevents any salt or trolling. But I also don't think you will lose your Mav title. It's not for the DAO to decide, since this is in the Company's control - so make sure you express to Aggy and the team that you bought with this promise in mind!
it could have been a good proposal by easing the access for future mavs. but that he wants to exclude existing mavs only shows that there are malicious motives behind it!
e.g. he could have just added the 100k sps as an additional option. so either you buy 1k packs in the store or you stake 100k sps no matter what you have of the two you get the mav title. that would have been a suggestion i would have voted for in my opinion. because that would improve access and give more people access. but excluding people is just disgusting