I guess the threadcast is already closed as the time window passed by, regardless I wanted to react, so I'll do it here.
Personally I am 100% sure we need something like Hivewatchers policing the chain as I don't think people should earn (big) rewards for posting for example ai content. BUT I think you're hitting the nail on the right side about transparency. Now I see posts being downvoted without any explanations while I see other people with relatively high reputations 'abuse' the reward system without any problems.
I think the difficulty though would lie in having 'clear rules' as you already mentioned as well. It's a very subjective matter, what shouldn't be tolerated? Ai generated posts? Automated posts / giveaways? Plagiarism? Giveaways of tokens worth $0,00001?
I think we, as the total hive community, should have a global vision on this theme which is nearly impossible because its subjective characteristics.
I checked the threadcast and if I'm right, there were only a couple of reactions (so far), which is a pity as this is such an important, atleast in my eyes, topic for all of us involved with hive.
I would be glad to think with you about how to fulfill the #hivecleanteam in a more transparent and/ or more complementary way to Hivewatchers.
Will definitely try to keep up to date with this topic!
The threadcast is still open by the way brother. i get notified of any replies. i think it's a good place to consolidate any discussion regarding the #Hivewatchers / #CleanTeam discussion. In general new comments under posts like this get missed by people who have already read the post (unless they bookmark it with ecency as they will then receive notification off all new comments).
Yes, giveaway tokens are something to consider, as to whether or not they are just for farming the reward pool or actually have a good use-case & bring value to the Hive ecosystem (digital).
i totally agree that a system like Hivewatchers is necessary to keep the blockchain "clean".
So, it would be great to have a post which is kept updated with "clear rules" which are agreed upon by consensus. i invite you to join the ongoing discussion (mostly just me talking to myself at the moment :-).
The consensus process itself is also a further topic for discussion which i would have a lot to contribute, in particular about how a Trusted reputation needs to be part of a consensus mechanism.
Thanks lots for your response
Potential Terms to add to Leo Glossary: - @taskmaster4450
Glossary, LeoGlossary, HiveWatchers, Status Quo, Ecency, Trusted Reputation
Misinterpreted the " I'll be active in the threadcast for several hours" as it would have been closed down later on, my bad 🙈
Will check it out / interact where I can!
Unfortunately many people reply to the comments instead of making new comment in the threadcast which makes it more difficult to read everyone's input.
Following is all #feedback for LeoDevs, particularly for @khaleelkazi - It would be very good if a warning message (like the current one when posting a link in threads) could appear when users attempt to reply to a thread in a threadcast instead of at the top level.
Something like
i made that mistake the first time i joined a threadcast and could not see them appear, so tried again a couple of times (then got ticked off by taskmaster4450 for spamming :-)
if you take a look at this threadcast you'll see what i mean, so many replies are buried (and it's very difficult for me to read them all & try to repost them at the top level to make them visible):
Note (another issue) : the reason i put the link in both clear text and a link is because (as you can see in root post above) in Inleo UI you can see multiple copies of the link preview if the link is posted multiple times. AND users who see the link preview often don't realise it is actually clickable to take them to the threadcast.
Copy & Paste into new browser tab this Clear Link:
inleo.io/threads/view/atma.love/re-leothreads-2mfwkpzlv
Or
Click the hyperlink or image whichever one that appears directly under this sentence:
https://inleo.io/threads/view/atma.love/re-leothreads-2mfwkpzlv
I definitely agree with the given feedback, was trying to read the threadcast, not that easy 😅