To add - I came across Genesis after the Peter Gabriel times - prefer Phil over Peter and then leanred what they did before - this was though during my AOR times so i favoures the US rock stuff such as foreigner, Journey, boston, Styx and such but Phil convinced me - the turn to more commercial was not a bad move even for me as consumer.
But to me the most legendary one is Follow you, follow me (still admire Phil from a drummer to one of the mo0st successful ever music artists):
And on Abacap (ok I have to confess beoing a balad rock guy) I really loved "man on the corner"
'Follow You'.. was a product of 1978, when they were starting the slow transition to the band that you like! I love it too, but it's been overplayed.
The album it came from was also quite sketchy, but does contain 'Burning Rope' and 'Down and Out', great tracks. Do look them up.
I know all the others you list, though I kept away from the band until 'Mama' popped up in 1983. That got my attention.