I am digging all the ideas you've listed only other ones I would say is those tipping tallies could not only be shown in HIVE but all coins like swap.BTC and stuff. If people also see they can earn tips in other crypto it might get them hot and heavy and its a powerful marketing statement to say this person earned say 0.1 in BTC tips etc
What would also be cool are UI tip jar or funding jar updates so users can tip into the jar for a certain cause, kinda like those back a buddy sites do!
How do you envision what you refer to as a "Tipping Tally" we are interested in ideas like this and wonder what others have in mind.