Part 3/9:
Proponents of the argument against live-action adaptations, including a prominent voice in the discussion, urge audiences to question the merit of retelling animated stories in a different format without adding any new artistic elements. The critics contend that these adaptations follow a formula that strips away the imaginative qualities inherent in animation.
Recent trailers, such as those for “How to Train Your Dragon,” reveal striking similarities between the new live-action versions and their animated originals. Notably, key scenes are replicated almost verbatim, leading to accusations that studios are failing to innovate. For many, it feels disheartening to witness a rehash of a story they already know instead of being offered an invitation to a fresh narrative.