Part 6/9:
Despite his inclination towards kindness and forgiveness, Manwë's decisions regarding Melkor raise important ethical considerations. Once Melkor was captured and imprisoned for three ages, he pleaded for clemency upon his release, and eventually, Manwë's compassion led him to believe that Melkor had changed. Unfortunately, this naïveté resulted in dire consequences, as Melkor returned to wreak havoc in Valinor, showcasing the dangers of unchecked forgiveness.
Moreover, Isaac highlights that Manwë’s kindness also extended to those who rebelled against the Valar, like Feanor and Galadriel. He sent forth spies in the form of eagles to watch over them, revealing his constant concern for the well-being of all beings, even when they chose paths contrary to the Valar’s intentions.