Part 2/7:
Isaac expresses gratitude for the respectful nature of the discussions, highlighting that while opinions varied, they remained grounded in thoughtful arguments and textual citations. He feels proud to be a part of such a community of Tolkien enthusiasts who engage in dialogue over disagreements without resorting to disrespectful remarks.
The Core Argument: Was Melkor Weaker?
The crux of the debate lies in the assertion that Melkor, despite being incredibly powerful, fled the battlefield upon hearing Tulkas’s laughter. Critics argue that if Melkor was indeed the most powerful Valar, how could he succumb to fear and escape? Isaac acknowledges this viewpoint but counters it with a well-reasoned analysis.