Part 3/7:
From 2018 to 2022, McNeil boasted a career batting average of .307 and consistently ranked in the top 30 major league hitters for various metrics including OPS and WRC+. However, a concerning trend began in 2021 when he only managed a .251 average. The Mets seemingly overlooked these warning signs, opting instead to extend McNeil in hopes of securing his services for a reasonable rate.
Interestingly, the breakdown of McNeil's contract was structured to account for his future earning potential while also managing the luxury tax implications for the team. McNeil's 2023 season saw him struggle considerably, reinforcing worries about the value of his ongoing contract.