Part 5/8:
As the investigation unfolded, the presence of a bloody axe and the absence of Patsey led authorities to question her whereabouts. Soon after, Patsey presented herself to the sheriff, tearing up the narrative with her claim that she had been hiding from her father to escape his rage due to his drunkenness.
However, inconsistencies and emerging evidence created a web of suspicion that extended beyond the O’Neals. The focus turned to Upton and Stephens, whose arrival at the farm earlier that day coincided eerily with the time of the fire.
Following their questioning, inconsistencies and alibis put them in the frame of suspicion as well. Rumors escalated, but it was Patsey’s tragic tale that captured attention.