Part 4/9:
Critics have pointed out inconsistencies in McCarthy's ability to lead the team throughout the season. Questions arise about the apparent absence of strong leadership in the first half of the season compared to the recent surge in performances following their playoff elimination. Now that there are fewer expectations, some argue that the team plays with renewed freedom—a stark contrast to earlier in the season when they were under pressure.
Others argue that while McCarthy may be achieving results in the face of adversity, this should not overshadow the larger picture of the Cowboys’ overall performance. The consistency of winning under duress rather than in crucial moments is something that many believe should be addressed if the franchise seeks genuine competitive success.