Part 6/7:
In the broader context of player evaluation, the Blue Jays—and indeed every organization—must continually assess the contributions versus expectations of their players. Historically, franchises consider various thresholds for how much latitude to give a player regarding their performance. For instance, players like Francisco Lindor might get a longer leash due to past accolades, whereas a player like Scherzer may face immediate scrutiny due to his injury history and age.
As the season unfolds, maintaining clarity and decisiveness in decisions about roster management is crucial. Scherzer’s short timeframe in the rotation could serve as a broader lesson in the volatility of investing heavily in aging players, especially those whose performance may already be in decline.