Fantasticly written post highlighting what witnesses represent, the power they have and a very clear perspective on the current governance model.
You are touching on many points in this post and really highlighting them clearly.
As i see it the challenge we have is how to govern a system with many diverging interests. As Hive/Steem was originally envisioned, moderation was intended to be somehow built into the base layer using economic and social incentives. Downvotes were added but its not clear if they actually are useful. They are clearly being used by some influential accounts to shape Hive in their view of the world. I don't know what the answer is but i would ask one thing
Stick with the Hive ecosystem to find a solution
Different witnesses could be the answer, i am not even going to begin to list my grievances as this post is long enough but they have also done a lot of good. We are in a good place on Hive but there is obviously work to do. Maybe a regular election cycle or campaign season for witnesses would help. There is not enough rotation at the top. When we see the top 20 competing for their places and seeking support we will be in a good place and i hope Hive can be a home for people with lots of different beliefs and philosophies