INLEO has been building Web3 exclusively on the Hive blockchain for nearly 6 years now. We were founded on July 3rd, 2019. Our mission has always been to build the best product we could possibly build. The INLEO UI and LeoDex Cross-Chain Trading UI are a testament to our relentless efforts to build the best Web3 experience in the world.
We've always been focused on bringing new users to Hive from the outside. We've collaborated with other projects and ecosystems and also keep closely in touch with them. We find out what their users, investors and community members want. A drastic shift in direction was taken over the past 12 months as we finally realized that the path to onboarding millions of Hivers and making HIVE.
As many of you know, we released a proposal on the Hive DHF about 1.5 years ago to expand our project to the outside world and onboard more users to Hive. The proposal promised to bring 10,000+ Monthly Active Users to Hive through INLEO.
We succeeded in that mission and INLEO's growth throughout 2024 was quite dramatic. We did several campaigns throughout 2024 that ranged from small to large. Toward the end of 2024, it accelerated. The Dash partnership alone brought 7,000 signups, millions of views on PR content related to "INLEO x Dash" and the Dash team now tweets about INLEO and Hive on a near-daily basis:
A few people have questioned the validity of INLEO's data. We have always reported data in our blog posts. Our team also does multiple weekly podcasts:
- AMA with Khal every Tuesday @ Noon EST
- Chain Chatter every Wednesday @ Noon EST
- Growth Calls intermittently on Thursdays @ Noon EST
In addition to all of that, the team is hyperactive on Threads and Posts. We constantly talk about our data and share it openly.
With that in mind, there have been a lot of people questioning how its possible that INLEO grew so much in 2024. Especially with a lot of activity coming toward the end of the year.
Dash is a ~$300M-$1B ecosystem, one of the oldest and most recognized projects in the industry. If you ask a normie if they've heard of Dash, many of them will say yes.
Having this brand name, large userbase and big pool of capital collaborate with a tiny project like INLEO had a huge impact on our ability to do 2 critical things:
- Onboard new users
- Reach out to projects like Solana, Arbitrum, ChainLink, ChainFlip, Base, etc.
We gained a lot of clout from this INLEO x Dash campaign, as I'm sure many of you have seen the wild surge in X Activity around the INLEO, Dash and Hive co-marketing campaigns.
Definitions
Let's address the elephant in the room: data and definitions.
On Traditional Social Media platforms (Web2), a Monthly Active User is defined as a signed-in user of the platform. This is someone who comes to the platform on a regular basis (at least 1x per month) and interacts with the platform in some form or fashion.
INLEO measures our Monthly Active Users (MAUs) in the same way. They are signed-in users who interact with the platform in some form or fashion. We further break this down into Monthly Active Creators and Monthly Active Consumers. We outlined this very clearly in all of the data we published throughout 2024. Culminating with our blog post at the end of the year that showed our final figures, post-dash integration.
- A Monthly Active Creator (MAC) is someone who creates posts, comments, threads, shorts or long-form videos on INLEO
- A Monthly Active Consumer is someone who interacts with any content on the INLEO site but does not create anything. There are many other buttons to interact with content than just creating it: this can be bookmarking content, sharing content, voting on content (manually, as we are able to exclude autovoters), staking HIVE, trading via their wallet on https://inleo.io through LeoDex, etc.)
Users are about more than just Creators. On Hive, we are accustomed to a culture where nearly everyone creates. Thanks to the Rewards Pool model for HIVE & LEO, users have built-in incentives to create posts, threads, shorts, videos and comment on other users' content. This is an awesome aspect of Hive but does that mean we should overlook the Consumer of content that reads, bookmarks, shares, stakes hive, trades hive assets, etc.?
On traditional social media, more than 95% of all users are consumers. 5% or less of all signed-in users actually create anything unique.
We've always measured our KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) in a similar fashion to Web2. We supercharge them because we have access to a lot more data thanks to the Hive Blockchain.
With our new Proposal live to grant us the funding we need to onboard 10 more ecosystems like Dash (Solana, ChainFlip, ChainLink, Arbitrum Foundation, Base, etc.), we have seen a few people say that they don't like the way we add consumers to our total MAUs figures. Even though this is an industry standard practice.
That all being said, INLEOs Creator-to-Consumer ratio is absolutely unmatched in the social media space. More than 38% of all INLEO signed-in users are Creators. The rest are Consumers who interact with content/features on the site but don't uniquely create their own content.
That is far and away superior to other Social Medias.
Data - New Real-Time Dashboard
The new Real-Time INLEO User Stats Dashboard is LIVE! Sign in and view it at https://inleo.io/stats.
A few people have pulled sample sets of data from Hive and used them to try and tell people how INLEO's "real" user matrix breaks down. The average user, investor and HIVE Stakeholder is not going to spend their time pulling SQL data and sifting through it. They are left believing whoever tells them the story of the data they see. Whether that be our posts or someone else's.
We understand this and can see why people are concerned. To address these concerns, we decided to Open the Kimono on our data, what we're gathering and how we interpret it.
These concerns came up over the past few days and yesterday morning, I decided to tell the entire INLEO Dev team to shift priorities for 1 day so we could build a Dashboard with Open APIs and allow any stakeholder on Hive to access the data, in real-time.
Not only can you see the final numbers in real-time, you can actually Download the raw data that we are pulling from the Hive blockchain so that you can reproduce the figures shown on our dashboard.
Normally, you'd need access to certain things, knowledge of SQL and a lot of valuable time in order to pull this data.
We want to squash all the beef and end the debate around our data. We believe in what we are doing and the ~30M in HIVE POWER that is voting for the INLEO DHF Proposal so that we can rinse & repeat our "Join INLEO, Earn Dash" campaign with 10 other $1B+ crypto ecosystems also believes in what we're doing.
We want to make sure that everyone has a level playing field when it comes to data. Full transparency. No making up data or choosing sample sets.
Monthly Active Creators (MACs)
We still track and measure our Monthly Active User count as a combination of the following metrics:
- A Monthly Active Creator (MAC) is someone who creates posts, comments, threads, shorts or long-form videos on INLEO
- A Monthly Active Consumer is someone who interacts with any content on the INLEO site but does not create anything. There are many other buttons to interact with content than just creating it: this can be bookmarking content, sharing content, voting on content (manually, as we are able to exclude autovoters), staking HIVE, trading via their wallet on https://inleo.io through LeoDex, etc.)
On the Dashboard, we decided to show Monthly Active Creators (MACs) since this seems to be the number that most on Hive want to see clearly and in real-time. With transparent data to back it up.
That being said, we still have the ratio of Creators to Consumers and the total User count on INLEO.
Not every user who uses the platform is going to create unique content. That is okay! Don't we all want more consumers for the content on Hive? Don't we want more people buying HIVE and staking it?
We still account for those metrics but this Dashboard will prominently display the "Creators" figure as a KPI for INLEO's Success.
HIVE POWER & LEO POWER of Active INLEO Users
This metric was called into question by pulling a random sample set of data. We decided to pull all of the data of users who are actively creating and voting for content on INLEO.
29,356,043 HIVE POWER and 17,831,255 LEO POWER has actively voted on on INLEO in the past 30 days.
MAC Trend and Signups
The trend of Creators is displayed in the middle of the page. It currently goes back to September, 2023, where INLEO had just 1,054 creators on the platform.
ICYMI, INLEO's UI was not in the same place in late 2023 that it is in today. We were adding a lot of experimental features and still building the core "Project Blank" product that you see today.
As that was released and the UI made dramatic improvements in both stability and feature set, we saw a significant rise in MAUs and Monthly Active Creators. Throughout 2024, we steadily grew these numbers and fostered a strong community on INLEO through out various marketing initiatives.
I met Joel in Croatia at HiveFest 2024 and we immediately hit it off. He wanted to bring the whole Dash community to Hive and get them active. He had a few requirements:
- Users needed to be able to sign in with Dash
- Users needed to be able to seamlessly trade/interact/transact with Dash
- The UI needed to look like it was built with Dash in mind (Payouts displayed in DASH, theme colors, etc.)
I said that all of this was possible and that Dash is a very large ecosystem with a heavily active Userbase. If we could make this happen and collaborate with Dash, it would have a signifcantly positive impact in our Monthly Active Userbase.
Some of the users coming from Dash would become active creators on INLEO - creating threads, posts, shorts and videos. Some of the users coming from Dash would become active consumers on INLEO - interacting with content on a regular basis.
The success of the INLEO x Dash campaign has been felt dramatically and it is seen very clearly in the data. Toward the end of 2024, INLEO exploded in terms of growth.
As with many things, you have significant rise upwards. A lot of new users try the platform... They may make 1 or a few threads and then leave. That's all okay. The key is: can you settle somewhere in the middle? We're all familiar with that chart in crypto: you start low, spike super high and then return to the median.
That is a positive thing if it happens when you're trying to grow a userbase. It means that you brought in a spike of attention and signups and some of those people stayed. Others may not have stayed.
We account for this in our data. We also found some heavy bot activity (across all of Hive, not unique to us) around the end of December/the period ending January 4th). This has been one source of criticism on our blog post about the 2024 user stats on INLEO, despite us saying that we accounted for these bots and do not include any known AI/bot accounts on INLEO User Stats. Any known AI/bot accounts were accounted for in our data and removed from all the charts and historical data. This can be seen transparently on the Dashboard UI and if anyone downloads the raw data:
Full Transparency
The raw data download is nearly 1GB. We're working on the ability to compress and share the data more easily. Check back on the Stats dashboard regularly for updates. We want to make sure that anyone on Hive can easily download the raw data that the Dashboard pulls every 24 hours in order to verify its accuracy.
The Future of Hive and How to Make HIVE's Market Cap Grow
our vision of the future. Collaborating with the largest projects in crypto and bringing them all to Hive. Just like we did with Dash
We believe that partnering with 10 more ecosystems like Dash is how we'll see this ecosystem flourish like never before. These ecosystems that we have lined up have multiple billions of dollars in market cap. They have everything from your average user to your largest whale. It's important to make them understand Hive and bring them over to Hive.
Our partnership and collab with Dash made it perfectly clear to us and everyone else: allowing these ecosystems to use INLEO as if it was built for their ecosystem, while letting Hive be the middle layer is the key to success for Hive's future:
- Sign in with their preferred crypto wallet
- Create content and earn in their preferred crypto
- Trade, engage and transact in their preferred crypto
Questions, Comments, Concerns, Feedback?
Defining and interpreting data can be messy. Everyone has their own definitions and has their own agenda. We have an agenda and so do others.
What doesn't lie is the raw data. We hope this dashboard can serve as the nail in the coffin on this conversation about data and user activity on INLEO. We made the dashboard radically transparent and you can download the raw data and re-run it yourself to reproduce the exact numbers displayed on it.
We know that this can be messy and confusing. We know that there are both supportive and opposing viewpoints on INLEO, our data and our proposal.
We are open to all of the feedback and how we can improve. We want to make Hive thrive. We want to see this platform flourish with millions of monthly active users - creators and consumers - we want to see more listings for HIVE on Centralized Exchanges and Decentralized Exchanges. We want to see more HIVE POWER staked and actively curating content.
Just like we did with the INLEO x Dash collaboration, we can do this with the next 10 collaborations to come.
If you support these ideals and want to see Hive grow to new heights and the market cap of HIVE expand like never before, consider voting the INLEO Proposal on Hive's DHF. We hope that we've been radically transparent with all of our data and that our relentless commitment to making innovative technologies on Hive has proven that we are loyal to this chain and want nothing but collective abundance for every Hive user, consumer, creator, investor and innovator.
Posted Using INLEO
Consumers are pretty much needed for social media to thrive, it's what makes it valuable for creators, and it's what matters for things like ads and other revenue models that are part of social media, so it makes sense to include them, specially when the crypto audience often explore more and talk less.
It's great to see all the data available for everyone to judge by themselves instead of having someone else telling them what they should thing.
I would say, most people will be able to see the impact the Dash partnership has had on Inleo, and how it benefits Hive. More of those partnerships will really improve our social experience, and very important, our tokenomics, as many crypto savvy people joins Inleo and start staking LEO, staking HIVE, trading, things we also need to grow.
Great to see you are taking steps to provide the necessary insights for people to independently verify claims being made. This kind of responsibility is one of the few tools that creators have in a decentralised environment to be able to establish themselves as trustworthy.
As I mentioned in our DMs, the key factor for me here is not so much the data and numbers themselves, but the ability to verify that the new users are real people who bring some kind of value to the chain. One of the primary goals of digital marketing is to not only bring in traffic, but to attempt to bring in targeted and QUALIFIED traffic, that is likely to bring value and to convert into some kind of behaviour that achieves the goals of the organisation.
Tracking the wallet sizes and engagement levels of the new accounts is certainly relevant to this process, but to fully respond to the claims of malfeasance, it is necessary to go a few steps further. Providing the full data dump should hopefully be sufficient to allow the community to do whatever due diligence they prefer with regard to clarifying the situation for themselves. However, as I mentioned previously, the best possible test here (and for all hive projects that onboard new users) is to find ways for the new users to meet and greet with existing users.
The age of AI unfortunately means that we can no longer trust the majority of internet activity as having originated in a human being. While it is an interesting conundrum that AIs could theoretically be given accounts on Hive and completely fool almost everyone into thinking they are human - earning tokens along the way - we are at least currently able to verify people through video calls and other methods. In the face of accusations of fraud and where this avenue is the only one that is open to really prove the situation one way or another, I look forward to some steps being taken to address this.
I want to reiterate that this is a problem that faces ALL projects on Hive that seek funding for marketing or that make claims about onboarding - in that no-one can truly know the accuracy of the claims without such human-to-human interactions being involved. In many ways this is similar to social support funding operated by governments, which are hugely targeted with false claims - just because false claims can be made does not imply that those running the schemes are scammers, but it does mean that some kind of quality testing is needed.
Cheers!
Hey Ura, thanks for taking the time to drop by and leave your feedback. Thank you for all the feedback as well as it helped guide the development of this dashboard.
I fully agree with this. The way we parse the data we're retrieving for the dashboard has some filtering when we parse for "Real Creators"
For example, here on the MACs trend, you can see ~2120 accounts were removed from the data as we found them to be AI generated/operated (or at least appeared to be).
The way we did that is by parsing the data with specific filters. We've created a handful of filters like these - and as AI gets smarter, we will need to continually tweak our filters. Hive is no stranger to people trying to game the system, even for pennies worth of rewards. Our goal is to filter out as much of that as we are capable through both automated and manual tactics. A few of the automated filters:
I invite anyone to download the raw data and confirm our filtering. If anyone has suggestions on how to filter better after doing so, I am all ears and will implement more filtering mechanics.
I fully agree here. After speaking with you and others, I realized the best way to respond to this is to build & release this dashboard and also the raw data that is pulled onchain to display the data.
We use the #newlions tag and a few other tags to filter for new accounts created. We also have a referral tracking system that helps users see who was onboarded from their links (i.e. if you share a blog post link, it attaches your referral ID and if anyone signs up from it within 30 days, they are attached to your account and you can view them in your Referral Dashboard on INLEO). We modeled this after Amazon's Affiliate program (30 day cookie dropped in the link clicker's browser. If they sign up within 30 days, the original referrer gets credit).
Quality testing is absolutely essential. I 100% agree. We will continue to work hard to filter people out, parse data better and have both automated and manual ways of finding the humans. Thank you for all your feedback 🦁
No problem, I am glad to help.
It's great that you are filtering for bots, though it may make sense to not publish the filters being used in future! ;)
I'll check out the full data dump once it's available and update asap.
This is awesome!!! This is truly what blockchain is supposed to be all about: complete transparency. The numbers are there for everyone to see and now you don't have to be a tech-wiz to get them so we can all judge for ourselves the progress being made. We're all in this together and we're all on Hive and Inleo to be part of a community that can thrive, grow, and ultimately revolutionize social media and beyond.
before things get crazy so everyone can be on the same page moving forward.Thank you @khal and team for confronting this issue head on and taking all the guesswork out of it. These are the kinds of things that need to be put in place
I literally get more excited every day about being a part of this community. It's coming!!! I don't know when, but it's coming! LFG!!! 🦁 🦁 🦁 🚀
This is an impressive presentation by InLeo. Thank you for being open to criticism and turning it to be a growth tool. It's always part of the growth process anywhere.
I've had no regrets Sticking with InLeo since 2020 having seen the focus on adding value to Hive.
I remember sharing the stats page of "X" last two weeks. I'm glad it's live on InLeo, Hive.
I see that 2025 is the growth year for Hive and InLeo is showing how to get that done. I hope the proposal would pass soon so we see Solana, Chainflip and others join InLeo
Cheers to us.
There is no doubt that everything possible is being done to make the great leap we deserve. INLEO has evolved impressively, reflecting the commitment, dedication, and transparency of those building this ever-growing technology.
With the arrival of Dash to join INLEO, we have seen an exponential increase in the user base. I can't imagine when those massive chains that will help us grow like never before arrive to our ecosystem. Not only INLEO, but also HIVE will be impacted by this growth, proving to be at the level of the great exponents.
Undoubtedly, we have very good content creators, but those who consume that content are also important. Why? Let's start by saying that they prefer to spend their time in this expanding ecosystem, and that they could also find in our ecosystem, a trace of belonging. By this I mean that we will see more lions, because what is being built and who represents it are absolutely great things that anyone would like to be a part of.
For that and much more, I am very happy to be part of INLEO and feel like a lion! 🦁 🚀
Collaborating with massive chains like Dash is the key to growing hive and INLEO. It’s a no brainer
They’ve got billions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of users, holders and investors
I agree with you as well that Hive has a lot of creators already. While we should always try to grow the # of creators, we shouldn’t overlook the importance of consumers. Hive needs more consumers and investors
Thank you for always being an amazing 🦁
Nothing is surprising. We have been tracking all the data since the beginning of 2024.
I could not count how many comments I left to the new Hive users first threads on InLEO!
It is sad to see that the projects that contribute to the growth of Hive ecosystem do not receive enough appreciations.
We will never stop building!
Hive On ✌️
Transparency and reliability. Nothing better than having access to the whole picture, displaying accurate data.
Onwards
My goal with this was to get everyone real-time access to the data. So that people who don't have access to SQL / know how to query data like this from the blockchain are able to see it as clear as everyone else.
No more obscurity. This is all real-time. If someone questions something they see on our dashboard, we provide all the raw data to reproduce it 🦁
As someone that loves stats the more the better!
I agree!
Is there a way to download the source data, as announced?
yes, check back on the page later today. We’re compressing the data to make it easier
Great, thanks!
This is great and we surely need more users (content creators and consumers) on hive. After DASH collaboration a significant user onboarding was noticed. More partnerships with such big and popular projects will bring more users on board and this can make hive thrive.
100%. The key is more consumers and more creators!
where do i find the Stats for the Power of the Users? i would like to see the Toplist of it and how leofinance perform in that numbers.
Refresh the dashboard page later today and you'll be able to download all the raw data for the whole dashboard and reproduce any of the numbers you see with that data
Great!
This is awesome, love the stats, would be really nice if the dashboard for individual accounts reflected accurate figures too.
Also, within the wallet section, the $Hive estimated value aren't accurate.
Sometimes there are case by case issues with the old dashboard. If you post a thread with #feedback, I'll take a look and get it fixed for you
The stats on posts and thread counts seem to be accurate, the only problem is the reported rewards.
Hivestats:
INLEO:
Same period.
just so everyone in this post knows, you’re talking about Hivestats and also a separate dashboard (not the onboarding dashboard). Please report this on threads with #feedback as it’s unrelated to the post above
Yes, I pointed that out, clearly you missed it.
I didn’t. Our dev team logs issues as top level threads with #feedback. It won’t get fixed if it sits as a comment on an unrelated post
I put it there for you. Thanks for the feedback about the personal rewards display on hivestats vs inleo
This article is very interesting and informative. As a user of Hive and INLEO, I followed the development of the project and was impressed by its growth. I was particularly impressed by the partnership with Dash, which led to a significant increase in the number of users.
I like that INLEO openly shares data and is not afraid of criticism. This inspires trust and respect." I hope that other projects will follow suit and become more transparent.
I would like to learn more about exactly how the partnership with Dash has affected the growth of INLEO. What specific actions were taken? How did this affect the user experience? It would be interesting to hear about this in future publications.
A dashboard well done, congrats.
It would be interesting to see how graph figures corelate to campaigns.
And yes, definitions can hide a lot of things. People will always doubt, no matter what you say !INDEED
We keep pushing forward no matter what. Data doesn't lie and we know the platform is more vibrant than ever even from a subjective viewpoint. Onboard em' all to Hive