ICE's $2 Million Contract With a Spyware Vendor Is Under White House Review
Immigration and Customs Enforcement's contract with Paragon Solutions faces scrutiny over whether it complies with the Biden administration's executive order on spyware, WIRED has learned.
The Spyware Crisis: A Threat to National Security and Human Rights in Europe
The use of spyware has become a growing concern in Europe, with several countries facing allegations of using the technology to target political opponents, journalists, and dissidents. While the United States has taken steps to address the issue, European governments have been slow to respond, leaving their citizens vulnerable to national security threats and human rights violations.
In recent months, several countries have launched investigations into the use of spyware, but the results have been mixed. Poland launched an inquiry into the previous government's use of spyware, while Spain's probe has led to no accusations against those involved. Greece's investigation cleared government agencies of any wrongdoing. However, these efforts have been criticized for being inadequate and lacking transparency.
Despite these investigations, experts warn that the use of spyware poses a significant threat to national security and human rights in Europe. Scott-Railton, a researcher at Citizen Lab, argues that European governments are failing to address the issue at scale, despite the presence of domestic and export-related international issues. The lack of a comprehensive approach has created a "huge mess" that undermines national security and human rights, according to Krapiva, a researcher at Access nOW.
One of the key concerns is the potential for spyware to be used by hostile foreign governments to target European officials and citizens. In August, Google's Threat Analysis Group found that Russian government hackers were using exploits made by spyware companies NSO Group and Intellexa. Meanwhile, Access NOW and Citizen Lab speculated that Estonia may have been behind the hacking of exiled Russian journalists, dissidents, and others using NSO Group's Pegasus spyware.
The use of spyware by European governments to target political opponents and dissidents is also a major concern. Krapiva argues that some European countries are using the same tools against the same people that Russia is targeting, creating a "huge mess" that undermines national security. This raises concerns about the potential for human rights violations and the erosion of trust in government.
The US has taken a different approach, emphasizing the national security aspect of the issue in its executive order. The order focuses on the deployment of spyware technology in accordance with human rights and the rule of law, as well as mitigating counterintelligence risks, such as the targeting of US officials. This approach recognizes the twin human rights and national security threats posed by spyware and prioritizes the protection of citizens.
Experts argue that European governments should follow the US lead and recognize the twin human rights and national security threats posed by spyware. Until they do, they will be at a significant security disadvantage. The use of spyware is a complex issue that requires a comprehensive approach that balances national security concerns with human rights considerations.
To address this crisis, European governments should take immediate action to:
By taking these steps, European governments can help to mitigate the risks posed by spyware and protect their citizens from the threats posed by this technology.
Article