Does the US Even Have a Middle Class Any More?

in OCD4 years ago (edited)

You wanna talk about the protests going on in America right now? Well, there’s a certain historical aspect that I don’t feel qualified to talk about. I suggest you listen to the hundreds of very eloquent African-Americans out there speaking out on this issue.

From my perspective, and I grew up a member of the lower middle class in the American South living right next to and going to schools that were 50% African-American, racism is woven into the very fabric of America. It is institutionalized in our Constitution. My Southern family and friends may like to contend with this assertion, but the further I get away from the South, the more I realize that racism was the primary cause for the Civil War, America's most destructive war. This may surprise some of you, for I've only come to find out after traveling and living around the US and abroad extensively, but that is not what we were taught in public school. In the South, we still have it drilled into our head that the Civil War was about "state's rights" and nothing else.

But the older I get and the further I get from my birthplace, the more I realize that racism is a cancer which has plagued the American body politic, lo, these past 244 years. Though it sometimes goes into remission for years or even decades, it is always there, ready to rise up whenever the country experiences weakness. The coronavirus is definitely a weakness that has ripped the US apart. At one point, I've heard that more than half of black Americans became unemployed thanks to the virus. So it’s no surprise that at this point, the cancer came roaring back.

From an economics perspective, I’ve brought this up before, and very recently in my post "DeFi is The Way to Prevent Gini 1.0". The US “Gini coefficient,” that which measures the depth of a country’s rich-poor gap is way out of whack. And it’s been getting increasingly skewed since the Fed’s QE shenanigans began back in 2008.

No chart can make this claim clearer than this one.

image.png

China, which is by no means a Gini paragon, has been pulling hundreds of millions of people into the middle class this century, while the United States has been aggressively kicking them out. The results are in the chart below.

Mind you this is not an income chart. It’s a wealth chart. And nothing amplifies wealth like low interest rates, which have been a fixture of US policy for 12 years and look like they will continue for quite some time.

Combine that with a razor-thin social safety net and a consumer culture that eschews saving, and you have a recipe for economic ruin for the bottom 2/3 of the American socioeconomic ladder.

No wonder people are lootin’ mad.

So what do we do now? I'd say the best thing to do is just listen patiently to our best cancer doctors (that would be the peaceful non-violent African and African-American activists that have been so eloquent about their response to this crisis), and we’ll be better off for it in the long run. We'll never be able to truly feel their pain, but we can do our best to understand it better.

We can also try to create better economic policies that don't create such stark divisions between the haves and have-nots.

Whatever it is we're doing now is no good for the majority of people in America.

The riots are in no small part about that systemic wealth inequality.

Posted Using LeoFinance

Sort:  

The challenge is the interest that is inherent in the monetary system. There is not enough money to pay back the debt tied to its creation PLUS the interest. This creates the scarcity situation where it is a race to be one who is able to get the resources. Being "credit worthy" is another way of saying being able to enter the interest game.

For the past 100 plus years, when we look at the population, broken down into 10% tiles, we see that only two of them were net interest recipients. As you can guess, it was the top 2 tiers. Everyone else ended up being net interest losers, with the middle tiers being the biggest losers.

Thus, the middle class was systemically being wiped out, regardless of what the interest rates were or how smart the upper tier thought they were. Simply being in the top classes entitled those few to bilk the middle class without any effort.

It is a process that continues today.

Posted Using LeoFinance

Interesting. Where do you get that data from?

Join the conversation on Twitter, #PoSh.

We still have it drilled into our head that the Civil War was about "state's rights" and nothing else.

This is a function of where you grew up. In the South, the emphasis is on state's rights (to do what?). Everywhere else the emphasis is on slavery.

I thought I had made that clear, but changed the wording a bit to make that even moreso. State's rightS!

Posted Using LeoFinance