I liked the idea of the higher contributing members filling the spots. I am about to enter my 1st fray after about a month being new to the guild and I don't think it is fair that people who just randomly joined take those spots. Mainly because I understand that those who were before me have dedicated much more and I waited until I caught up on contributions. With that being said, if someone more dedicated to the guild wants my brawl position I will give it up but that does not work when id give up my spot and see someone less dedicated in a fray I would want.