You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: How To Make A Universe 101 - Can We?

in StemSocial3 years ago

Don't worry about it. I know how busy you are, and I really have no idea how you keep up with all that you do :) I only moderate a community plus few other minor things and RL, and barely finding enough time to write and post once a week and/or read and keep up with things.

About the energy conservation:
It "can", but with current theories, Noether's theorem, and data, it "is" violated on that timescale due to no translation invariance in an expanding universe as you have mentioned.

Regarding CMB energy loss;
As far as I know, there isn't as nearly CMB to cover for it. Dark energy is increasing at a much higher rate than the CMB loses energy.

Ofcourse, we are not throwing out conservation of energy or the second law of thermodynamics (which is another topic), as violations are only on such extremes and it is unhelpful to do so.

Thanks for the always insightful comments, and wish you a wonderful week too!

Sort:  
 3 years ago  

Thanks for this replies, which I agree with. Let me come back to one point:

As far as I know, there isn't as nearly CMB to cover for it. Dark energy is increasing at a much higher rate than the CMB loses energy.

Let me be more specific: the CMB contributes to it. It does not need to take it all. I was probably a bit too sloppy in my initial comment ;)

After looking a bit on the web, I have found this very nice blog on the topic. This goes along the same lines as my comment, but in a more expanded manner. The more important item it points out is that we must be careful even with the way we define energy in an expanding universe.

Thanks for the always insightful comments, and wish you a wonderful week too!

Unfortunately, the disasters are back since this morning :(

OMG, it's the same article I found and read right after reading your first comment and doing some Googling about the topic. xD

Yeah, I totally agree with what you said after the initial misunderstanding got cleared up now.

Unfortunately, the disasters are back since this morning :(
Ouch! Really hope nothing too big or unmanageable. :(
 3 years ago  

Ahaha nice coincidence. In fact, it is not the first time I get to this blog when browsing extra material online. This is a very good one.

Ouch! Really hope nothing too big or unmanageable. :(

Manageable, but painful emotionaly.

Sorry to hear that man :(

 3 years ago  

This is how it is, unfortunately...