You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: The Proposal System is fundamentally broken!

in #hive5 years ago

Things would have been way easier if devs implemented a downvote button next to "support" button. That way those who disagree with specific proposals could downvote it. I mean downvote buttons are everywhere so why not there too?

Right now one can only support a proposal...or ignore it. Of course one can also vote the return proposal so that the funding limit goes higher but it's not the same thing.

Sort:  

I wonder why that is the case. There must be some reasoning behind it. One which I'm not able to come up with.

I have no idea. Don't get me wrong here, I ain't suggesting that she doesn't deserve all that money...nor that she does.

Generally speaking there's no way for one to express their disagreement on proposals. Voting the return proposal higher would affect all proposals that receive funding atm.

I get where you are coming from but do you really think it's worth 30k though?

I think there's a simple explanation for that: in a (stake-based) system by representation disapproval has no value. Only approval does. It doesn't matter if you disagree, as long as sufficient approve...

Harsh (is it?) but true. If you disagree, your task is to alter the minds of those agreeing.

Another argument would be "brigading", an issue which we have historically seen through all voting based communities online. Brigading of witnesses and proposals would make the environment only more toxic here.

Well, there is currently no way to show disapproval so you are right. Being able to downvote proposals would fix this. Changing the minds of those who agree is Sisyphus' work.