Something different this #needleworkmonday … I am at a loss how to proceede. The eternal question of which buttons to use has risen from the deep see. It is grabbing with its tentacles of endless pain after my tender brain: should I use something funny, complementary, or muted and understated, should I choose a colour already in the knitted item, should I go for nerdy or sensible?
This is not the first time I have problems choosing buttons for a handmade cardigan. When I am browsing other crafters finished cardigans I am always in awe how beautiful and sometimes daring button combinations they use. But me…? If I choose something daring, I afterwards love the photos of the cardigan, but in reality, often have nothing to wear it with, because the buttons are too “loud”. If I choose simple wooden buttons the cardigan is more wearable, but often I feel it gets a touch of earth muffin (in German there is the phrase ‘ökig’ which means: sustainable but bland and unstylish looking). Besides I hate don’t like to sew, so I prefer to use bigger but less buttons.
Although I have approx. 34 some unfinished pieces lying around, I started another cardigan. (The soft pink carding is still not finished….sewing….. perhaps you remind it from two weeks ago) I found some bright green wool in my stash and wanted to make a spring-welcoming jacket. Sadly, I did not have enough wool and (sigh 😜) had to buy some new to complement the green one.
In the end I made a cropped top-down sweater with a garter stitch yoke and a stockinette body in self striping yarn. Now I am finished and started to crochet the button band – I prefer crochet button bands because I think they are sturdier and faster to make – and noticed that again the wool will not suffice. I compromised and made the left band with the rest of the green wool and the right band with the variegated yarn. But before I can make the actual button holes I have to decide which buttons I should use….
HELPPPPPPP PLEASEEEEEE
Currently the small green ones are my favourites, but they are small. Really small. The smallest button hole I can crochet will be one chain wide, I am not sure if this will be to big for this tiny button.
My next choice would be the brown button with the carved flower – I simply like these buttons so much. But this is the combination I think is not very stylish.
The dark ones fit also very well, but it’s such a dark combination… (I want spring)
The buttons with the stars I think are cool and a bit nerdy, but I am unsure, if the cardigan with the star buttons will fit anything in my wardrobe (besides a black skirt)
You are all so fit in choosing wonderful colour combinations for your projects, so I would heartily appreciate your opinion 💕 💕
I enjoyed reading your post!! I too sometimes have a really hard time at choosing which buttons to use for a finished project! Although it will be easier for awhile since I lost a full size bag of buttons and appliqués! 😫🤦🏽♀️ Sorry about the side vent, now back to your post...
I personally love the small green buttons too! I love that they blend in but yet still stand out because of the shine on them! I am normally a woodsy button person but I do like to play around with colors too! I hope you can make the button holes work for them! 😉 Beautiful cardigan BTW!! Love he colors!!! 😘
Loosing so many buttons - not funny! Here are buttons quite expensive (if you do not buy them via china on ebay) So this is a real loss. The same goes for appliques, which I handle like a treasure :-D
I made the buttonholes some hours ago, but haven't sewn on the buttons. I think it will go with the small green ones and they are big enough (Yeah :-DDD) Sadly I have again such sh** migraines (no yeah to hormones). I crawl into the bed now...
I agree! It is not funny loosing buttons or appliqués, I am soo heart broken but won’t give up looking for them!
Yay!! I’m so glad you decided to go with the green ones :D
Oh no migraines are no fun! You get you some good rest and I hope they stay away.
Hello my darling! First, I really like the color of the cardigan! He's so rich and bright) second, as for the buttons - I would choose brown. I think, they look good on a green background and at the same time they are not screaming. If you want a more versatile option, maybe even consider black buttons?
No don't tempt me with another option ;-D
I firstly did not liked the color combination so much and thought I made a mistake by mixing them so wildly, but right now I am with you and really pleased (thank you for the praise). An hour ago I made the button holes and the small green ones and the brown ones will fit - the decision has to wait till tomorrow (I have bad headaches .... again... mähhhh)
I think I will go to bed now ...
Oh, yeah, you know, you and I used to say that you often have to move away from the decision and just go to bed, and in the morning to make a decision on a fresh head. Goodnight! And remember-any decision will be correct! I believe in you)
Ich finde die orange farbenen wegen des Kontrastes am besten!
Das Gestrickte ist wunderschön geworden und ich liebe Grün! Das Stricken bei Kaffee & Kuchen sieht sehr gemütlich aus.
Danke für diese angenehme Einladung zum Handarbeiten. :)
Es war auch sehr gemütlich, vor allem da wir den Kuchen geschenkt bekommen haben. Es ist ein neues Cafe bei uns in der Nähe und ein ebenfalls neuer Mitarbeiter hat eine Torte beim schneiden 'zerstört', sie wurde dann als Probe zum Kaffe verteilt :-D
Schade das wir den kaffee nur virtuell teilen können. Ich hatte auch deine neuen Post gesehen, lag aber mal wider mit Migräne flach, da fällt mir lesen und vor allem sinnvolles kommentieren schwer. Ich hoffe es bleibt bei mir jetzt ok, dann hole ich das nach :-D
I thought the darkest ones were black, but you say they are dark brown...Hmmmm, I think black would be my choice, but really any of them are fine! I like the green and grey yarn combo!
Yes on the photo they seem to be very dark, but they are brown. Currently I have no black ones in my stash.
Happy you like the yarn combo... it was improvised and I forstly thought it will not fit. But now I am happy with it.
I would go green because of springtime. This is such a beautiful green that it needs something bright and cute. Anyway you decide is the best way - just my two cents.
Thank you for helping me decide (I will tell my decision next monday :-D) 💕
I prefer the brown one to complete the earthy colors you have here. Although the others blend in well except for the one with stars in it.
I think you are right, the star buttons do not fit so well (but I like the buttons themselves so much :-D) Thank you for helping me decide :-D
It's the best I can do :)
A lovely cardigan, @neumannsalva! As for the button, I think I will go with the brown as they enrich the colors in the cardigan.
Thank you for your feedback. I will write (hopefully) next monday which of the buttons made the race :-D
What a darling cardigan you have made, @neumannsalva! The greens are stunning! My favorite buttons for this cardigan are picured on the top right of the four square panel. I love the wood-look and the contrasting orange/brownish color. I completely empathize with your agony over button selection--I go through the same anguish when I am trying to select beads for my lamps!! You are not alone on this. Happy #NeedleworkMonday to you, my dear!
Thank youuuuu and I can imagine deciding on beads and pearls must be tough. Perhaps I would simply omit the deciding and start to play with them... you know like with marbles 😆) I considered this with the buttons too... but they did not roll very well.
Absolutely lovely cardigan 😁 I have this problem often - especially when putting buttons on my er-upholstered chairs! I find going crazy is all good fun at the time, but if you plan to wear the cardigan you might see it differently when that time comes. I would go with the dark brown ones. Good luck in deciding - please let us know what you went for! 😁
Thank you!! And I will let you know (hopefull next monday) I am also really pleased with this cardigan. I bought this patttern and modified it to fit me better. It's Carlise cardigan by Tara-Lynn Morrison. I like her designes very much.
The blouse is super!
Thank you. I think I also like it very much.... I want to put it on, but the sleeves are not seamed (yeah and the buttons) :-D
Hello @neumannsalva... I like the colours and the buttons and I would choose one of each design and alternate and then you can make an actual design feature with the buttons too :)
(perhaps too quirky I know.... but I like buttons and I have more than one jar of my favourite ones ! )
hahaha, funny, that was my initial thought but then once @neumannsalva said that the ones with star are hard to combine with other clothes, i didnt even mention it :D
Nooooooo another alternative noooooooooo 😆😆
I am so bad a diciding such things. And yes your idea is also very lovely, perhaps I have to sleep on it (today i will look if I can make buttonholes which match the small green ones, if it does not function, they are out of the play)
Follow me @erwinpante and I follow You
Thanks
Teurimong Geunaseh
thank you for your support - I will look at your profile, I follow only people with interesting content.
I love the ones with stars and then brown ones
thank you for your feedback. Do you mean the dark brown ones (they are almost black) or the lighter ones?
sorry, i mean lighter ones :)
nothing to be sorry for. I have not had perfect light for the photos and just was not sure if you could see the color well :-D
Right now I am trying out the little green ones, but as written above I like the light browns too (ahhhh decisions)
I like the ones in the last photo, RHS
Thank you for the feedback. And it seams the star buttons may win :-D
I like the contrast of the brown buttons. Very good work. Receive this upvote from @nextvote team.
Thank you for your support. And as written above the light brown ones are my favorite too.
The star buttons are really fun and a small green ones look really nice too. Go with the ones you like the best and don't worry about if they match other pieces of clothing.
If you wear it with something, then they match.
Also I really like name Butthulu! <3
Yeah... but we should not write the name a third time - I fear what will happen 😱 I am now trying the small green ones to see if I can make a matching buttonhole.... Thank you for your feedback 💕
It is the green ones and if they are not big enough you must make a crochet cover for them. Or go shopping again 😎
Very Nice. This is a compliment from an Artist to an Artist! :)
Thank you and happy you like my post.