You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Male Privilege: Is It Real?

in #life8 years ago

I feel like statistics like these rarely paint an accurate picture because so much is left unsaid. For example, are men getting longer sentences than women for the same crimes? Or are more men committing more serious crimes than women?

Personally, I think we'll all benefit when we finally stop making decisions based on gender. Women have proven that they can serve their countries in combat and work industrial jobs and men have proven that they can parent their children. And yet, for whatever reason, we insist on viewing these things as exceptions to the rule instead of encouraging and accepting them as the new norm.

Sort:  

That's a fantastic comment!! Wow. 0.0

It was a very interesting post -- and definitely worth thinking about. Thanks for sharing it!

Indeed, not to mention "industrial deaths and accidents" when 90%+ of the workers in that field are in fact men.

I agree, this infographic is not a fine-tuned enough instrument for identity politics...for the reasons mentioned by the amazing @redhens who I am about to follow! And another:

Identity politics logically amounts to radical individualism, whereby every data point in existence modulates the intersectionality equation. This results in combinatorial explosion: too many variables to solve for at once, all emerged in feedback loops. See the film, "Synecdoche New York" http://m.imdb.com/title/tt0383028/

Also want to add my thanks for bringing up a controversial topic that affects our lives,

Identity politics is radically individualistic....?

That seems contradictory
:/

It is indeed self-contradictory, and needs a reductio ad absurdum to refute it. The movie I shared is that absurdity played out on screen.

Identity politics tries to put us into demographic boxes and label those boxes "identity". Then intersectionality comes along and starts refining the categories of people in the boxes. For example, a gay Latino man may have male privilege, but it is intersected by lack of privilege due to lgbt and ethnicity discrimination.....A person's identity is too many intersections to apply broadly across a culture. It's absurd. :)