While the platform was built by anarchists, we all arrived inside a structure, with immutable rules in place before we were even invited. So, I think you've proven my point. Within the structure, anything is possible, but the limits are set by an oversight, governing committee, democratically elected to that position, so there's that. That process was also in place before we arrived to live out our digital fantasy.
You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
No, because your point wasn't "rules make things work smoothly".
If that's what you had been saying, I'd have agreed and these posts wouldn't have happened.
Your point had to do with the mindset of anarchists and whether they plan things out ahead of time or they believe we can wait until the state is gone.
And now you're trying to pretend your point was something different so that you can accuse me of having proved it.
#GotchaGames
All anarchists would agree with you that rules are important.
The rules that govern us in a voluntary world are emergent, and not perfectly knowable by anyone ahead of time.
"I don't know exactly what the rules will be" is different than "rules aren't important"
So no, this did nothing for your point.
If I understand you correctly, you are trying to convey the concept that the game world itself will always be dependent on real world circumstances that existed before the game was created.
This is accurate, but as you can see from us suggesting the game in the first place (working withing our current structure) there is nothing that is definitely preventing us from creating a new concept or "space" for our ideas.
That's what we are doing here. We are creating this new "space" where we can try out new things. The only reason it is worth doing is because by us designing it and creating our avatars "early", we are being able to set our priorities before others that might want to see a different society form join up. That is the only reason we have more influence over this particular structure.
Apart from that, it should become as much a microcosm of the real world as possible. But without it, there would certainly be little to no opportunity in the first place.
My last comment was in reference to an earlier comment and referred to the steemit platform altogether. I realize the anarchical element is, I don't HAVE to participate in steem, but its hard to model real world conditions, because everyone HAS to live somewhere. Sorry, caps for emphasis, not volume.
I think your game is a great step toward modeling voluntary society, steem on.
I absolutely agree that creating an accurate simulation of human life and also implementing the type of society we actually want is a difficult task. We've discussed this in the Slack channel and will probably continue discussing it as the project progresses.
Thank you for your comment and support.