You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: The intentional miseducation of society

in #philosophy6 years ago

I disagree with the fact that what I say is "just an anecdote". This is something I have seen in my own university and that colleagues have seen in their own universities too. Moreover, there is about 10% of unemployment in France (I however actually don't know how many of these unemployed people have a university degree).

Let me just finally also insist that I was not thinking about "literate people" but "people with a university degree (or similar)". Mmmh actually I didn't mention it but this is what I was thinking about :)

Sort:  

I didn't say it was "just an anecdote", I said it was "anecdotal evidence", which Wikipedia defines as

[...] evidence collected in a casual or informal manner and relying heavily or entirely on personal testimony.

In formal studies researches are required to go to some lengths to remove any personal bias from the process, at least if they are researching scientifically. I'm sure your observations are relevant but the knowledge is not transferrable to me because I cannot trust it's validity. If there is 10% unemployment in France then that is a fact, unrelated entirely to your observations.

In my opinion if you cannot recognize your observations may be biased then you are not practicing a level of skepticism and humility necessary for genuine inquiry.

I agree there is no evidence backing up my claim. Just some gut feeling coming from discussions with many people and my own observations.

But please note that I had never the intention to sell this as a scientific claim or evidence of what so ever. I made it clear from the start.

Understood. I'm also just making clear that I can't accept it.

Sure, no problem.