How about earning a PoGoodwill badge versus deserving a PoEvil label, where a PoG badge qualifies one for stronger up-votes and a PoE label qualifies one for weaker up-votes and a PoE labelled member will have to earn the equivalent of a PoG qualification in order to cancel the PoE label.
I suppose that is the way up-voting and down-voting (flagging) is supposed to work, but does it?
If qualifying for either the label or the badge requires a number of votes by distinctly different account holders, would it perhaps make a significant difference?