NO
I don't think the features should be merged. Hiding from seeing (muting) is not the same as wanting to hide from replies on a blog (moderating).
I think people being able to moderate their own blog (the latter feature) is okay as long as there is a prominent label indicating that poster moderation is active. And it might be debatable whether this should even be allowed on posts which aren't reward-declined, because if they aren't then it isn't really a 'private' personally-owned blog post but one which has chosen to participate in the shared reward pool.
Also consider how this will work with communities, which probably should be able to have their own rules on what sort of moderation is allowed or required for that particular community.
Great points here. It keeps coming back to communities with how best to improve the social experience on here. We can't get those shipped soon enough.
They're getting closer. And the great part is that it's not a hardfork need.
We need them done yesterday.
How about just moving them down (regardless of Sort Order)?
Or semi-hiding (like currently downvoted comments are shown) with info that's
[MUTED BY AUTHOR]Also, if visitor follows someone, who's muted by the author, then it shouldn't be affected at all (explicitly stated preference of visitor).
+1 for semi-hiding and preference of visitor.
I still don't know if it is systemically good for the author to be able to unilaterally hide comments from (nearly) everyone. In practice most people won't dig through [muted by author] comments and can easily be fooled by scammers, plagiarists, etc.
I prefer the downvoting model where it becomes a consensus, not unilateral, matter whether a comment gets hidden or not. Perhaps the author could get some extra temporary vote weight for this (considered paid for by the act of posting).
I very much question, particularly after HF21 with free downvotes, whether truly abusive comments won't get consensus downvoted by others. Already it mostly happens that way. The hidden comments are generally the truly garbage/abusive/disgusting ones.
Putting author-disapproved comments at the bottom of the sort order facilitates a variant of forum sliding where the author can (via sock puppet/collaborators) post many author-approved comments to push the author-disapproved ones so far down that no one ever sees them.
Some of these could also be used to help hide abusive rewards in the comments, too.
I really like this type of implementation.