Cheap-Ass Beer Review Smackdown Party Festival 2017: Pabst Blue Ribbon vs Coors Banquet

in #review8 years ago

Coors Banquet
vs.
Pabst Blue Ribbon


...gather up those pennies, it's time to drink beer!

Pabst Blue Ribbon (PBR)



Playing shows and drinking PBR: they go together like peas and carrots to me. (Photo captured by @jasonrussell)

History Lesson Time

Well, the can isn't lying to you when it says prominently that it was "Established in Milwaukee in 1844," and the beer bottles themselves, between the years of 1882 and 1916, actually had a literal blue ribbon tied around it. In 1892, during PBR's glory days, the brewing company actually needed to purchase a million feet of silk to make the ribbon to keep up with the demand of their beer. Makes sense that they just print it on there now.


Vintage marketing at its absolute finest.

A Few Fun Facts About PBR

  • Pabst Blue Ribbon has always claimed it was named "America's Best Beer" at the World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago in 1893, however, the actual truth of whether or not the beer won any award at the event at all is unclear--some even stating no such award was even given out at that fair.

  • Pabst Brewing Company was originally Best Brewing. The name was changed to Pabst in 1890 after the son-in-law of the Best company took over the brewery.

  • Resurgence in PBR's popularity, specifically among hipsters and punk rockers, is credited by many to as the modern salvation of PBR. Because of its conservative roots, PBR is resistant to completely embrace that alternative image, so they utilize more subtle sponsorship marketing of alternative and artistically driven events. They intentionally stay away from traditionally mainstream advertising opportunities (such as the Super Bowl), and in turn have helped steer a generation of young-ass drinkers to the old-ass beer. ("Don't come to us--we'll come to you.")

  • PBR's Merch Store is a perfect testament to this alternative branding, featuring everything from Snapbacks, to mitten Koozies, to a $6,400 PBR pinball machine. There is even such a thing as a PBR-branded Koozie Belt. (Basically, I want to own everything on the entire website. I wish PBR would sponsor me with their clothes.)



Let's Drink This Cheap-Ass Beer!

Appearance: 4/5

  • PBR is a light golden beer, fairly close to what is describe as piss colored. It is perfectly clear with small bubbles and a nice presence of carbonation even in appearance. I've always appreciated it for its watery nature, but in paying attention, I was surprised to see it had a (for a cheap-ass beer) a nice, frothy head that didn't completely dissipate. I have included an in-the-glass shot so you can see what I'm talking about. Fancy!
    Inside the glass after about five minutes.

Smell: 3.5/5

  • Bright, crisp smell with balanced tones of grains and citrus. I can almost smell grapefruits and canoe trips.

Taste: 3.5/5

  • PBR has a lager taste without a heavy aftertaste. I don't like a beer that coats my mouth with a film, and PBR does the trick. The grains are more prevalent in the taste than in the nose, and the carbonation of those fun little bubbles is refreshing and makes it pop upon the first refreshing sips.

Feel: 3/5

  • While it has a heavier feel than some other domestic lagers, it is just watery enough to finish clean and the carbonation adds to the refreshment of the mouthfeel. Beware: While refreshingly and light when cold, this cheap-ass beer gets funky and thick in warmer temps quickly.

Overall: 4/5

  • PBR is a great all-around beer for those looking for something a little less conventional than the standard American domestic cheap-ass selection. It has a nice body and it actually has flavor considering the cheap-ass price. It has been and will continue to be my go-to show beer for both sides of the stage.

Cheap-Ass Rating:

3.6 out of 5

Cheap-Ass Weighted Scale:

71.6%



Beer Advocate says: 70/100

BA.com average user rating: 3.01/5





Coors Banquet



Smokey and the Bandit: This movie really is pure swill and features truly some of the worst acting ever to be captured on film, but it has some great car chases, and I still love it.


History Lesson Time

Coors Brewing Company was originally founded in 1873 in Golden Colorado. Coors is a company whose marketing has consistently posited its heritage in the Rocky Mountains, and the benefits of the water there, as what sets it apart from other American style lagers.


I couldn't pass up the opportunity to share this gem of a campaign from 1982.

A Few Fun (and not so fun) Facts About Coors Banquet

  • Coors adopted the name Banquet for its beer as a testament to the Colorado miners who were the first customers of the burgeoning brewing company. The story goes that when the miners would have a large gathering and a group meal, that a good beer needed to be present. Enter Coors: the banquet beer.

  • Founder Adolph Coors died during prohibition in 1929 and it was ruled as a suicide from jumping from a hotel window, but it has been speculated whether or not he jumped or was pushed. Some accounted his depression due to prohibition, but others contested a suicide was not in his nature. Scandalous.

  • In response to the old-is-new/hipster/steampunk revolution, Coors brought back not only the historically significant stubby bottles (as seen in the title image), but also the prominent feature of the word Banquet on its logo and major branding. (This line of marketing totally works on me. I am a sucker for beer bottles and labels that look old/vintage. I used to hunt for old glass bottles as a kid, so maybe that's part of it, I don't know. Regardless--I'll be discussing this further with Miller Lite next time.)



Let's Drink This Cheap-Ass Beer!


Appearance: 3/5

  • This beer is beautifully golden in color and almost perfectly clear. Its head quickly dissipated into what an eager achiever might call lace, but not quite. There were also almost no bubbles upon pour.

Smell: 2.75/5

  • At first the smell put me off, as the first notes were bitter, almost like sour citrus. As I smelled again, a crisp smell grabbed my attention and as it warmed I could smell Granny Smith apples spot-on.

Taste: 2.5/5

  • For what I call a full-bodied vintage-style American domestic beer ("old beer"), this one is on par with most in taste. Crisp, but alcoholy taste that changed in balance from crisp to alcohol quickly with air and warmth. It was getting the boozy warm beer taste at a much cooler temperature than other beers in its same category.

Feel: 3/5

  • Crisp, yet a slightly fuller body in comparison to other domestic lagers. Also, I wished it had more carbonation.

Overall: 2.75/5

  • Banquet is heavier and more bitter than what my taste buds prefer when it comes to cheap-ass beer. For as watery as the beer appears in its clear golden tones, it is heavier than it appears. While fuller in body, it still maintains a crisp edge. Carbonation was lacking and the bitterness in overall flavor isn't super palatable to me. I expect a beer of this caliber to be more generally refreshing.

Cheap-Ass Rating:

2.8 out of 5

Cheap-Ass Weighted Scale:

53.8%



Beer Advocate says: 64/100

BA.com average user rating: 2.7/5



Scoring the Beer

The instrument used to score the cheap-ass brews is from Beer Advocate...because I'm an amateur taster only pretending to know what I'm talking about and needed some kind of scale and this site knows their shit.


Appearance = 6%
Smell = 24%
Taste = 40%
Feel = 10%
Overall = 20%

Total = 100%


...and the cheap-ass smackdown champion is

PABST BLUE RIBBON


It comes as no surprise to me that PBR won this smackdown. I mean, as I mentioned in my previous post, I like a good, watery beer, and while PBR has flavor, it is also definitely watery to my particular specifications. I also think it's a refreshing alternative to many of the cheap beers on the market, and always a great value when it comes to the money.


Thank you for checking out the inaugural Cheap-Ass Beer Review Smackdown Party Festival 2017 Showdown between PBR and Coors Banquet.


The Next Smackdown...


I'm really looking forward to this next set of beers, as I have basically no bias, and I'm honestly not that sure that at this point I'd even be able to tell them apart, so I'm excited to dive into the nuances of the 'Merican Standards in Cheap-Ass Light Beer.



Cheers!



Sources

"Facts: Pabst Blue Ribbon Factory." National Geographic Channel. Ed. National Geographic Channel. National Geographic Partners, LLC, 03 Aug. 2012. Web. 14 Jan. 2017. http://channel.nationalgeographic.com/abandoned/articles/facts-pabst-blue-ribbon-factory/.
"Heritage." Coors Banquet. Ed. Coors Brewing Company. Coors Brewing Company, 19 Oct. 2016. Web. 14 Jan. 2017. https://www.coors.com/heritage.
Hiscott, Rebecca. "The Real Reason Hipsters Love PBR." The Huffington Post. The Huffington Post, 29 May 2014. Web. 14 Jan. 2017. http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/5399109.
Peterson, Simon. "Top 7 Facts about Coors." Best Beer HQ. Best Beer HQ, 19 Aug. 2015. Web. 14 Jan. 2017. http://www.bestbeerhq.com/top-7-facts-about-coors/.
White, Sara. "Why Coors Is Called the 'Banquet Beer'." MillerCoors Behind the Beer. MillerCoors, 25 Nov. 2016. Web. 14 Jan. 2017. http://www.millercoorsblog.com/history/coors-banquet-beer/.

Image Sources

Coors Banquet Logo Source
Pabst Blue Ribbon Logo Source
Smokey and The Bandit Movie Poster Source
Vintage Pabst Blue Ribbon Ad Source
Vintage Coors E.T. Ad Source




All thoughts expressed, images, art, words, digital collage, and other stuff not specifically credited otherwise is 100% bonafide original material. The images are hosted at Imgur.



Sort:  

I wasn't expecting such a detailed review, I enjoyed it :)

Awesome! I'm glad to hear it was pleasantly surprising! I want to give these cheap-ass brews the attention they deserve. Blazing the trail to end the bias against cheap beer. :) Thanks again for checking it out. I'll have the next smackdown up in a few days.

This was very fun to read! From experience, I prefer PBR over most beers. Busch Lattes are also a good choice.