I think both of them get the idea of the future wrong. Remember. There are science fiction movies of the 90's that portray 2010's with flying cars, A.I and all the other goodies. What we got instead? Plenty of hypes with little to no use. People thought for example that having a see through fridge would save us the trouble from opening it. Little did we know that the idea would fail since nobody is comfortable sharing their mess inside the fridge.
Not sure if I've read anything back then that indicated this in some pretty decently reasoned-out book or it was just portrayed simply as scifi.
Everything made is for the common folk. The average user. The only correct prediction I see for the future is Idiocracy. We be building more and more virtual reality spaces, more and more basic cyborgs to fuck and date. We will make our houses prisons that we won't have to leave for anything.
One of the most possible paths but still only a prediction, plus there'd always be a counter-culture..