Honestly while I approved of the idea, I'm a little disappointed with the engagement.
I wish that there had been some discussion or attempt to address any of the questions here before this moved into the game for final vote... this pre-proposal was authored, had limited engagement, and moved into the game without any responses, comments or any other indication whether any of the feedback was considered, or even read. No edits, no likes, no responses.
Splex says this proposal had 2% of staked SPS voting for it - by it's own standards it wouldn't even advance to the game for a vote. I get that the governance process isn't the most exciting thing in the Splintersphere, but this seems to have been completely forgotten about...
Maybe engagement would be higher in case already the pre-proposals were held in game, there, were the players actually are? :-)
Yes probably. I believe that eventually the pre-proposals will be better integrated in-game.
However, I was more speaking to the fact that there was no response or dialogue from the author of the proposal during the 7 day discussion period. I thought the intention of the preproposal period is to give an opportunity to gather feedback before it goes to an official vote in its final form. There was feedback, but I don't know if it was even read. That's all.