You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Self-voting user list since HF19

in #statistics7 years ago

there might be far worse than this list shows using multiple accounts.

You're definitely right here.

Doesn't it work the same in real life? People with more power are more visible and looked up against (the rich and famous), so they are held accountable for their actions more often than regular folk.

Sort:  

It seems like that but I think a lot of times we focus on he things they do that don't matter like who they are dating and what they tweet rather than how they make their money and who their true motives for doing things.

That's true. All about the juicy gossip. It's a world of extremes, where the fact that someone worked hard for what they got, or donates to a charity, is just not as interesting as what they did when they were drunk.

"so they are held accountable for their actions" - Are they really? Feels like the other way around at times. One example on how not to end up on this list -

Voting exchange: I see you have 100k SP as do I, we agree to vote one post from the other a day. You won't end up on this list, yet the end result is the same. This list will do very little in weeding out abusive voting. And this is something that came up my mind in 5 seconds - something far more sophisticated can be implemented with a bit of time. But yes, I do agree that this information should still be available and posted regularly.

I have the full list and all data. But it's wayyyyy too much data for 1 post so i have to filter it. In this case i just filtered everything under $100. Because, do we really care about people self-voting a few cents? Most people probably care way less about that than people self-voting thousands or even tens of thousands of Dollars each month, right?

Personally I care more about the percentage than the dollar amount.
I would love to see the list of people who self vote over 50% of their post.

You're right. Thanks for providing this info.

Fair point. The only people really able to battle a whale are other whales, so we can only call them out through lists like these.

You're right, there are a lot of ways to avoid getting on this list. Having multiple accounts is another one. I don't think there are any ways to catch every bad apple here, sadly. We'll just have to do what we can.

It shouldn't matter who voted for the post, what matters is if the post is over-valued.