I, @lturner, being of a regretful mind, choose to keep my one weapon and move on by choosing Option 1
- I have 1 Knife
- I need to eat by Day 4, Round 2
I'm not particularly concerned about a trap here, though it is interesting that a woman (we're not talking a big strapping ex-marine here, I'm guessing) carrying a target like a backpack is willing to approach a total stranger to ask for a weapon. My biggest concern is that I need my knife and I don't need to eat badly enough to trade it. I also wonder if the cans of food would be useless to me if I have nothing to open them with.
Even if I were willing to abandon ethics for gameplay, I wouldn't be surprised if she is good at self-defense and any attempt to overpower her ends up backfiring.