Wow, that was a really thoughtful and sideways angle on the question! I love it!
I had that thought in mind when I made the question. The idea that wishing for a particular superpower wouldn't really end up the way that you would think it would, and that there would be all sorts of downsides or unintended consequences from what should have been an ideal "gift"!
I think your choice of "superpower" is a superb choice!