Hey Steemit,
Yep, people are definitely voting for themselves, no surprise there. Here a particularly egregious example.
Sorry @kingscrown , but I have to call you out on this one.
Check out this exchange:
You can find it in my auction post:
https://steemit.com/delegation/@neoxian/for-auction-10k-delegated-steempower-for-one-week
##################################################################
########################################################################
Ok, so what happens here is that @parker.hammer is new in town and he asks a question about delegation and what the auction is all about, perfectly understandable.
And, a minnow @nnnhhh steps up the plate and actually gives a pretty decent answer. So @stevescoins and I upvote this user and give him about $1. Great! This is how Steemit is supposed to work. Give a nice answer, get some money, wonderful.
Then @kingscrown comes along and gives a very half-assed answer and acknowledges that @nnnhhh gave a good answer...
Then proceeds to upvote himself to the tune of 13$ and not that minnow at all....
wat
(look of disapproval!)
Come on man, geez? Throw those minnows a bone here. Doesn't the system reward you enough already? Every post you write earns at least 1000$ easy, share the love a little. I'm sure @nnnhhh would have been tickled pink to even get...like $5 for that comment, but you just stuffed it into your own fat pockets instead.
And check out his comment history:
https://steemit.com/@kingscrown/comments
Tens, Twenties, Fifties ..fuck. Welcome to HF 19 I guess, this is the new normal.
Look, I know I'm not a saint in this regard. I upvote myself plenty too, but I'm very aware when I'm doing it, and usually it's like...30 cents... And if I do go higher, it's because I feel like what I'm saying is pretty important and I want visibility.
You might not think people notice this stuff, but they do. The other day you were asking me to vote your Peerplays witness, well I remember stuff like this.
Oh, right after making this post I'm going to revote @nnnhhh and give him a better reward.
actually i was sure i have upvoted him - fixed now :)
u could pm me though - would be faster and less messy!
my posts get 100s (literally) comments and 1000s (literally!) views. the only way for me to sort stuff is with upvotes.
also the very post of your that you linked.. has a top upvote from me.
so sure i may miss a good comment or a vote sometimes yet took me 3 minutes to find this two but still im sure i upvoted more newbies to good money than many others..
not speaking of 100s of posts i upvote. so imo - case closed.
im sure attacking popular author is a cool thing though ;)
Honestly, you 2 are probably some of my favorite whales here on Steemit... if you are indeed whales. I don't really keep up with that.
I see more good come from you then most.
This conversation proves it, poking and picking yet still civil and polite. I sense a little bit of good fun here and it is great.
Thanks for making even a friendly bout be fun to read for members like myself.
haha, whales on the offense!
Very well said. There are people that keep it classy and civil regardless of the actual situation and we should take a hint from them!
Ok, thanks for giving that guy a good vote, I saw it. I guess I'm off your christmas card list now, oh well. I'm sure you do a lot of good things for Steemit and bear you no ill will. Sorry if it seems like I was picking on you, I'm sure there are much worse things going on here.
Next time I'll just PM you.
So I just tried upvoting come of my comments and I only got about a penny. How is someone else getting so much?
The payout value per vote is based on the amount of Steem Power you have. The more SP you have, the more your vote is worth.
You get a 100% too since you actually answered him lol.
lol I'll take it!!! By the way, since HF19 you only get 10 full power votes per day, unless you use the slider to drop the % when voting.
I hear you. Makes sense really. But I'm flying tomorrow so I won't be able to like...should use it all up and be fun now (before into back to being a hermit and voting for myself. Here have another one!
Hahahaha, just tossing them out left and right like Payout Santa lol, love it. Thanks again man!
You're welcome! Here comes Santa Claus, bam! Another one!
Ill give you a 100% vote from me. I've been on vacation and letting my 40 per day go to waste. :
Edit: and a 100% for me too because im selfish.
Thank you very much! That is so kind of you! I hope you enjoyed your vacation. Where did you go?
I'm in Germany right now actually. Drinking too many beers hence the generosity. Also I've been lazy with voting in steemit recently. Here have another 100%
Ah thank you! Maybe you should stop upvoting until you are sober!!!
I'm glad you're enjoying yourself there and have fun!
And another full power for looking out for.my health!
Love how many beer fans there are on here. I finally have a way to share my love of beer with the world lol...or is Steemit an excuse for me to go have new beers every week so I can post about them??? hmmm. Either way, beer lovers unite!
Ill be posting a review of some of these German beers. Maybe one long post since descriptions will be short (memory fuzziness).
I wrote a sarcastic beer review a while back. Thought it was quite funny but it's when.I was just starting out. Check it if you wanna laugh. (I laughed, bit I wrote it drunk again )
Someone said beer? :)
Definitely going to check it out lol. I'm down for a nice drunken review hahaha.
And a 100% from me which is 0.05 lol since I just made $51.81 on a comment below! More then I ever made on my posts! And I didn't upvote myself yet!
Wow that's awesome though. I bought Steem as an investment so I've only earned a fraction of my wallet. Most was right timing in the market. I can't match 51 but take one of my 100% votes
I did buy some Steem as an investment too I guess and then I though I might as well Power Up as I am HODL. But already made some author rewards left right and center which add up to a nice amount. Thanks for the 100% upvote 3.07 is massive.
Take another whatever it's worth now
Haha damn my lucky day!! Thank you!! Still worth a lot lol. You're making it sound like your giving a few cents away.
You are right. Whales have enough money, no need for upvoting own comments.
How much is enough? :)
Valid question.. Enough might seem like a $100 a post but when you make a $100 and you want to commit to Steemit, as you see more money to be made here then with your 9-5 job, then $100 a post might not be enough.
I get you point @neoxian and we should support newbies and people trying hard to grow but you never now what the exact situation is. Maybe @kingscrown invested thousands of dollars in his account and wants a decent ROI and paycheck. As you can see below he also upvotes a lot of other people.
We do not have to personally agree with anyone's upvoting decisions (i.e. whales upvoting themselves or anyone upvoting poor quality content), but that is the beauty of Steemit. We all have the freedom to operate in the Steemian universe as we see fit.
Ideally, quality content will be rewarded regardless of a person's status - minnow, dolphin, or whale. But as you build influence (and the whales have the most influence), you have more freedom and more responsibility in how that influence is used.
It is a problem with some people. However, there are some other pretty amazing whales. For the people who have less influence you can either invest a bunch money if you have it. Or you go to grind and slowly bulid your way up here.
I choose not dwell on the people who vote there own comments. At this time there is nothing we can do about it. Changes will come and we can push for the but at this time it adapt or be frustrated.
it's system's issue, how do you expect to people (whales they are or not) to limit their own rewards ? you can't force them to, and you can't complain about it, if you don't like it, then propose your solution to this (but this will very likely met with concerns)
I think its fine upvoting your own comments if you're an investor of this platform provided you will follow an acceptable time frame to get your ROI. In that range of time, you should put value to the system and appreciate the community thru giving some influence. In that case, it's a win win situation and no abuse will be practice.
In regards with ordinary user that built up their own empire(becoming a dolphin), its also allowable to upvote your own comments for you're putting so much time in the site and provided that you're re-investing it to the system and giving back something to the community.
omg, @neoxian is my hero. here, take my measly 100% upvote!!!
Bahahahahah love it, I had to resteem. That's why you got my vote Neoxian!! I know you have our backs.
Bah how can i not upvote such an awesome username!
I do get you two confused.
That's funny
And if i join in the fun
Haha thankx
I've seen that some of the bigger fish are getting a 4% growth rate per week just upvoting themselves since fork 19.. It seems very unstable. Hopefully that corrects it's self over time.
Yes, you're right. We have to support fellow steemians specially minnows who writes relevant comments/posts of sharing their thoughts.
Hi Neoxian,
I upvoted this for the potential of an interesting conversation. Thank you for bringing it up.
I have the same reaction, and although my account is small compared to some in the conversation I do vote for my posts, and depending on circumstances my comments. (mostly to raise their visibility)
So, asking a challenging question. At what level should someone quit voting for themselves? (In my opinion, there is no "right" answer) Just trying to get a feel for the reaction.
I "lol'd" at your "disapproving stare". :)
I think it can also become an issue when you are being delegated a bulk of your stake for curation purposes...then those votes go to yourself at much larger percentages than you're giving out to others.
It's like that Steem Guild issue all over again...
I agree with that. The responsibility for it should be in the hands of the delegator to ensure their stake is being used well.
How about 50/50?
I talked on @neoxian about his sp rental or delegation. 50%/50% upvotes for me/others sounds fair to everyone. That gives me 10-20% interest on my investment on delegation if steem will have a stable value or good median value. If I'll make it 30%/70% upvotes, Im throwing so much love on the community but there's a 30-40% chance that I can't get my ROI to rent SP again.
Above all these, I am only giving 5$ or less with my upvotes. A value that's incomparable to a 50-100$ self upvote. And lastly, this is still a mere plan. :)
Do you mean 50% of your daily votes to yourself? If that's what you're working out with your delegator, then that's between the two of you. That's not something I would do though and I don't think it's very helpful overall. Why not just buy the stake yourself instead of renting it at high rates?
I have delegated stake. I've been using it mostly on others. I only post about 5 times per week on average and only rarely vote my own comments. When I do, its a low percentage. For my blog posts, I generally vote right around the same amount that I use on other posts...sometimes slightly higher. But again - I only post about 5 times per week, and two of those are contests where I give away the liquid rewards.
Even doing that, I'm making some very good returns. Upvoting myself at 100% while giving a small fraction of that to others would make me feel pretty dirty. I don't understand why people feel the need to do that, especially when they're using stake that isn't even theirs...that they didn't invest themselves. It just seems very cheap and greedy to me.
Hmm, that's a really tough question and there is no easy, cut and dried answer, like most other voting in Steemit, this is subjective proof of work.
Certainly the two extremes: never voting yourself and always voting yourself sound wrong to me. It's ok to vote yourself sometimes, as long as you don't do it too much, too often, or too high value.
I vote myself when:
The situation I describe above in my post just felt wrong to me. If kingscrown had voted himself 7$ and nnnhhh 7$, I would have been fine with that.
Great answer, and from a really honest place. I knew there wasn't (1) answer, so we are all just figuring this out. (I do the same)
I enjoy the conversation around it. I am getting close to the place where I need to define this for myself.
lol @ your 'disapproving stare' comment :)
All this and grammar correction! Love SteemIt.
lol no, no no you got me all wrong ....I 100% agree with your comment. I was laughing at those glaring eyes too.
lol, got it. :) Either way, I wasn't offended. I thought about changing mine. Enjoy. (laughing again)
I'm LOLing at these comments 😂
I can't blame anyone for taking advantage As long as it's not excessive....but this doesn't seem very sustainable to me. Any news on tweaks to fix this or is whale masturbation just going to be encouraged?
No news on this.
Hi how can communicate you, regarding rent SP delegation. Thanks
I almost never upvote myself on comments, but i am minnow whit few cents, i do not mind if someone else upvote himself, only what i miss is that he could give maybe 2 or 5% to other. Like i expected, people will be very selective whit who they give upvotes.
I never upovoted for my own comment, but maybe things will change when my steempower will be ENORMOUS. Haha, we'll see. Great post by the way. ;)
iappreciated @neoxian
not only that but they are commenting and then not even upvoting your post! Disgusting.
it is not steem to the moon again. It is Greed to the moon insted. 😭😭
That does not need to be intentional. I often find myself want to write a comment, commenting and then forgetting to upvote.
This was something I was nervous about before HF19...I don't think there is anything inherently wrong with voting for oneself when it is deserved...and I think that the 4x voting power change was done to try and discourage self voting, but I am not sure how you would solve this problem to point people more in the direction of voting to curate good posts and comments...something to be thought about though for sure!
Guess with a community this big, there will bound to be all kinds of people with different thinking and objective. But am sure most of the people around are helpful folks like you : ) @neoxian.
It is one of the low points of the HF and I think the most significant ... Immediately after making a comment or making a post already many people have more than 20 dollars accredited and sometimes it does not feel fair. Obviously they struggled their way to the top but it discourages us a little at times.
How much does it cost him to upvote himself to get that amount? I guess he is taking advantage of this and even though it doesn't seem right, I guess I can't blame him if he is making money. And there is also something called random whale were you can pay it 2 SBD and it will upvote one of your post. Isn't that cheating?
Was always gonna happen! Check out exyles post on the subject. I like this guy a lot 👍🏾
I think I am too green, just know this "trick"...I voted my own reply before because a few more cents will make me rank higher in the reply trend, but the payout is little, didn't realize it can make a huge money.
The only time I've upvoted my comments since this began was the first day, but that day I went a little nuts upvoting everyone at full blast until I completely killed my voting power, lol. It was a good learning tool. I've left the autoupvote on my posts, but since then I haven't upvoted a single comment of mine. So while I'm sure people are doing it, not everyone is.
I noticed this too. Sometimes users will comment on a post - "great post" - and then upvote their comment but not the post. Upvoting one's own comments was always pretty crass, but this goes beyond.
@neoxian WOW - I didn't know this!
I've only been with steemit for 8 days so there is a lot I don't know LOL 😃
Thanks for explaining this, even if it will be gamed by those seeking the rewards.
I'm following you now because of this quality info, thanks.
I don't upvote my own comments, maybe it's because my votes aren't worth anything. Great post by the way. Followed for more good stuff!
Couldn't agree more!!! I've noticed that with a TON of heavy hitters. @sweetsssj does the same thing. She'll get like $2,000 for every post and I've never seen her give back anything to anyone. WEAK
Well the stats do show that @sweetsssj actually gives back to people. Edit: Sorry to go against you my friend didn't realize you made the comment lol! Anyways facts are facts!
Where do you see what people are giving by back? Every time I've looked at her posts, I've never seen a single one have an upvote by her
Check out steemnow.com and type in the name at the top right
Cool. Thanks for that. Still, when she's making 50K a month, she should be upvoting every single person every single time! Lol
I guess we'll find out who's right right here. If she doesn't upvote me for having her back and going against my Steemit mates I guess you win. If she does then I win. Deal? ;)
Lol. Deal!
She prolly invested in herself ;)
My rule of thumb usually is to upvote my own comment only if it get's a thread going. Then again that was before HF 19, and it was also when my upvote was like 10c 😅 I'm wondering what has changed about this now for me. Still wondering.
If you were running a witness I'd vote for you dawg just because of this post. I have nothing against @kingscrown as he's always been nice to me. Although itd be nice to see whales use HF19 for what it was designed for!
Actually...now that you mention it..I do run a witness.
Voting rn hold up brotha...
THERE!
Thanks!
Anytime brotha.
meep
And so it begins! Hahhaha, Yeah people will notice for sure and there are some people who will get greedy with their votes. I'm not one of those people. My voting power is at 22%. Everyone in the comment area gets a 100% upvote!
YOU're FUN @brianphobos !! - ))
.. and, what an insightful conversation !! - ))
SO many different perspectives !! - ))
... and the block chain KEEPS doing it's thinG - ))
IN the backGround .. a FUN crazy WorlD !! - ))
LOVELOVELOVE )))
greb'Z
Same on my blogs for the most part!
Freud would say you are measuring your cocks with steem hahaha
Thank you for expressing what we feel. <3
I had a funny one on Monday night, I put up just a silly pic of my horse, I got a few views, one "comment" came in nice enough, but his comment, I replied, he replied, didnt upvote either my pic or my 2 replies. I didn't get the con, the next day his 2 upvotes for himself- he paid himself 6 bucks, my post earned 54 cents, so yea sometimes it's too obvious....
DANG IT ... !!! ... i hear YOU ... ?? ... but ??? - (((
... KingSCrowN ... deserves ... to do as he pleases ( . )
i'm with YOU .. it'd BE nice " if "((enter harp sounds here)) ... but, at some point in the future, i'd like to have "power" .. an .. "accumulation of SP" .. and, BE a CURATING NINJA .. and, i believe WE are ALL looking forward to that day, for OUR-SELF !! - )) The "option" .. to do as " i " SEE FIT .. is pART o the reASon STEEM is so AMaZING !!! - )))
Again .. to SEE amazing acts of kind-ness .. is SWEET !!! - )))
... but ???
DO WE need to hold each other acount-able ?? ??
i watch CraiG GranT .. and, he is LIVING TESTAMENT !!! - )))
... that, he is GOING to STEEM the way 'he' wants to !!! - )))
RocK StarS ... don't KISS ALL the FanS - )))
... but they KISS ... some of them !! - ))
.. just some thoughts - ))
and ... a well presented story !! - ))
thanks for hearing me ))
LOVELOVELOVE )))
greb'Z )
PumpeD & reSTEEMed !! - ))
It is a real problem, but that's the way things are. The value proposition for this type of behavior is really high. I upvote my own posts. I don't shitpost. So, I don't feel bad about the $0.17 I pay myself for putting up good content.
But, at the same time, I only post 2-3 times a day and try to comment at least 10-12, spreading the love reflexively, because that's how you build communities.
In fact, I feel Steemit is at its best when it serves a strongly knit sub-community of 30-40 people who share a common interest and work together to support each other's work.
I'm doing everything I can to help people get there, even if all they do is just comment and Resteem, so they can build a nest egg of Steem Power and, in turn, support my work.
I encourage serious content creators to do that as well. I'm bringing my audience from Twitter and Periscope to Steemit and encouraging them to come out from behind the camera and show themselves to the world.
It's small, but I can see positive results in just a few days.
Thanks Neoxian. A good post and shame is a powerful motivator.
👍🏾
I gave in voting on my own comments, as a minnow. It doesn't raise them because my voting power isn't strong enough, it doesn't earn me much of anything and my votes are far more valuable in creating good will with people I meet.
Comments say hello, voting with a comment creates in investment in the relationship (makes that person realise you're serious about wanting to get to know them) especially since HF19, at least in my book, and it's a small book in a big pond lol
Cheers :)
you rock. nice lesson for that person,,at least a slap in the face. self upvoting is understandable, as long as you know you deserved it. but stuffing you full pocket too mucj will only make it break a bit.
I have not made my yellow but I was pretty happy when a comment of mine got a 5$ vote.
But @neoxian - self-upvoting has just become a little bit easier now for the whales, they could do this before too.
Granted, they had to do maybe 4 times the work, but with x² the overall "reward" was even bigger.
Wow, I guess enough is never enough sometimes...
Am I the only one on here that doesn't upvote his own comments? To what end? My own posts? Less and less. Those starting out may be the future of Steemit and regardless, add value to the platform as it grows.
@neoxion, I think you mentioned a very important component of upvoting that I have not heard anyone talk about yet - VISIBILITY
My personal upvote does very little in regards to payout, but I try to use it to make comments and reply more prominent. There are times when this is a valuable strategy, but everything could break loose if people start abusing it.
It's not as if he's making $1000 a post. Oh, he is...
Is that likely to change as all his supporters use up their voting power?
Dude this is very motivational to me. I really admire your thinking here and that is what keeps me coming back for more. Kick a bit to the little guys.
I mean isn't there a way to think about a post cap that would pay the author plenty, but would end up spreading more around especially for the new folks???
I think that we are all free to do what we want to do, I have been reading into this community for a while, and I'm going to put " The inner speaker on " pretty soon.
Its a little bit controversial that people put the fingers on the others,remember that judguing its pretty easy , accepting the behaviours of the rest and getting concentrated in what we want its a different thing, and way more complicated.
What if i upvote myself just because im really satisfy with my job in the post and i want it share it the most? what if just want to upgrade into the comunity, who says what is right or wrong? Tolerance of actions as long they are moraly correct its a must .
i vote for others pretty much exclusively but then again i really have no power to give lol. ive heard a lot of people say they do 50/50 for themselves and the community. alot of people have invested a lot of time and/or money into building up their steempower and i honestly can't falt someone too much for trying to profit from the time and/or money invested. i saw one guy saying basically his account is worth $1,000 per day because he can upvote himself 10x at $100 a pop. he said he typically goes 50/50 though.
Satire at its best!!!
Way to go @neoxian
#whalepower
I remember that you were the first one I saw to call that potential problem with HF19. Unfortunately, I'm sure that more and more accounts of all sizes will start doing the math and will not be spreading the love around as they used to in the previous iteration of the rewards system.
But in that context, whales that care become an asset of the platform that is even more crucial.
This article is about bringing justice.
I like it and it really come from a person with a good heart.
Thanks for visiting my post too @neoxian
I think you've just hit the hammer on the head, I'm only a new ( minnow) and I try to upvote most of my replies. I'm beginning to think that there perhaps groups of people just upvoteing each other? Enjoyed your post thank you mike
mmm.....
it's informative
thank you for sharing. neoxian~