Do you wanna create your relationships based on political borders?
Blockchain has often lured people by its characteristics of being decentralized, uncensored, borderless, trustless and universal appeal. We come to Steemit to be part of such a community which is open and free in real sense. But we are so much accustomed to our old ways of living our life that even on a blockchain platform we refuse to understand or participate in such an unrestricted and free eco-system. We are habitual slave and would like to build our own prison walls if we are suddenly let free by any miracle. It’s because we never dreamed of such an existence and we prefer to live in the old way as it is more familiar and seems normal to us. It’s human nature to resist change however better it may be.
Isn’t this exact same thing is happening in the blockchain arena too? ICOs are being subject to centralized control, KYC verification is the preferred or mandatory norm by most exchanges & governments as well as investors & traders of crypto-currencies, crypto exchanges are functioning within geographical limitations, etc. are signs which are going to limit the power of blockchain to a large extent. Unless and until we change our old mindset, we can’t move ahead in this revolutionary system.
What disappoint me on Steemit?
When I joined Steemit, everything looked good to me initially. But soon I found that it’s still not a truly decentralized, uncensored, borderless system of blockchain as I had previously assumed. We still have a long way to go for that! Currently, in this post, I’m going to talk about the presence of rampant regionalism which is creating imaginary boundaries amongst this amazing Steeming community here. I’d like to have your views on your acceptability of such discrimination and whether or not should we keep continuing with that.
Rampant Regionalism and Closed Community Culture
With reference to the political boundaries that humans have sketched on this planet, I’m an Indian citizen. Since birth I was declared an Indian citizen and remained as such. I never felt otherwise. It was only on joining Steemit community, I felt like a global citizen. But unfortunately for me that feeling was very short-lived. For a person or society accustomed to a citizenship of a specific region, it’s hard to transform into a cosmopolitan mindset. Soon I found out that there are several country-specific closed communities here who are interested to extend support and interactions only in their own community. There are several whales who belong to such groups and who upvotes accounts only from their regional community. E.g. a Chinese whale will upvote posts written only by their community members even that post was completely written in English. There are closed groups from countries like Philippines, Nigeria, Italy, France, China, Canada, Spain, Turkey, Pakistan, India, Indonesia, Australia etc. Many of them have their own Discord Servers or exclusive rooms on various servers. We all know about the Russian version of Steem, but that’s a different story. But there are many small countries which don’t have sufficient presence on Steem yet (and probably a lot of them won’t ever have) and couldn’t form any effective group in response to other groups. So they are perhaps unfortunate to be left out.
But I belong to a pretty large nation with a total number of Steemians ranking among the top 5 in the world. Naturally a group is present for all Indians. Indians not only have got their exclusive Discord server, they have their own rooms on Steemit Chat too. I’m constantly noticing requests to assign a particular tag viz. #india to all my posts so that fellow countrymen and whales can easily find you and show their solidarity with a huge upvote. Check a sample invitation post to launch such a server, I came across recently. I don’t know what other motive these country specific communities have. Yes, it do help when one wants to connect with people from particular area when he/she is travelling to those place, to seek local information or for any other reason but this can’t be done in these groups as membership is restricted to people from their region only. So these kind of initiatives are promoting a separatism, discriminating on the basis of a geographical territory and jeopardizing the opportunity for an open inter-exchange of culture & experiences openly across the globe.
#india Is The New TAG SCAM
Apart from creating a closely guarded regional community, there is another serious problem about the use of the tag #india by all Indian bloggers. When you are concerned with local issues and updates, you would search posts from the relevant tag. I think that is the whole purpose of tag to facilitate easy navigation to the intended content. So earlier I use to search this #india tag. But you now find all kinds of post created by Indians under this tag. If an Indian is writing about his / her trip to a European country, he will tag it with #india. How stupid! I find all general contents, crypto news and analysis, software news, philosophical articles, photographs, poems etc. under this tag. Ultimately, I had to stop navigating through this tag because of its widespread abuse..
Personally, I never use #india tag unless the article I’m writing is in someway directly related to India. I also expect to read the coverage and outlook of my country by foreign tourists & visitors under this tag. But Indians don’t expect them to use this tag! It is exclusively for Indian Stemians.
I think they should better do it with a tag like Indian or IndianBlogger to make it discerningly clear. Otherwise I consider this to be a tag scam. In fact, @steemcleaners should flag such a blatant misuse of tags. But there are so many tags without any distinctive use that they have become a khichdi kinda thing! E.g. tags like life, blog , hot, happy, knowledge, new etc. are so vague and can be used almost for everything you write. But #india has a clear connotation than these, yet if it is being used for all kinds of topics which are not necessarily specific to India then it should ring a warning bell for the watchdogs here.
Do leave your feedback, reactions and criticism in the comments below. I love positive interactions with you. If you just upvote my post, I do feel happy. But I'd be happier if you leave a comment too.
I sometimes send a small gift of 101 cents to 999 cents to one of the comments here depending upon my mood and account liquidity level. Hope you won't mind a small tip if sending that makes me happy.
If you are on Telegram, you may want to interact with my bot Veganizer or the Hindi version गौमाता कामधेनु. Do subscribe my Telegram Supergroup for chat related to veganism. Thank you for reading! 💓
Thank you for using DropAhead Votes_Plus channels!
Unfortunately, I have to inform you on behalf of DropAhead Team that we wouldn't be able to support your article with our votes as it doesn't comply with our copyright and intellectual property standards.
Meaning, we find your publication, complete or in its parts, might violate some third party copyright authorship through its misusage by missing or inappropriately provided citations, sources, credits, licenses, reusing rights or else. @xyzashu
Well @cessarespinozaa, no problem at all. But I'd appreciate if you can pin-point the exact content which you think violates copyright authorship.
Regarding citations, I'd like to tell you that not all copyleft material insist for a citation or a credit. So not providing a citation to such material is not a copyright violation according to law. It may not comply with your policy but you can not allege that I have violated any copyright and intellectual property laws. Thanks!
Okay, first of all, that was a very well-written article. I can see you put in a ton of effort, and I really think you will do well here with some more exposure.
In my opinion, there is a ton of writing, and majority of people have fairly short attention spans. So just consider that :) That is one of the main reasons why I make my posts into different parts. I would also consider adding some more visuals :)
I suppose I have to agree to some extent. Although the platform itself is very open, the people inside of it do make it less 'free to do as you wish' kind of vibes.
Keep up your work.
Thanks for your positive encouragement and valuable suggestions! I thought a 2-3 minute read should be a minimum if someone is really interested in the subject. But yes, I agree with you about the problem with short attention span and importance of eye-catching visuals. I'll try to take care of them. Thanks a lot for your time and feedback! A small tip! post ed to you for my pleasure.
Hi @enazwahsdarb! @xyzashu is sending you 0.101 SBD tip and @tipU upvote
:)
@tipU - send tips by writing tip! in the comment, get share of the profit :)you know, i hadn't thought about it, but the points you are raising are true. i have enjoyed that steemit is attracting people from all over the world, but now that you mention it maybe there is a segregation going on too. hmmm, it's a bit of a conundrum because many people may be attracted by relating to their regional/country community but others may want to be free from it and organize around thoughts or interests only. I think you are very much ahead of the curb on this thinking... very important as steemit looks to branch into more communities in the future and questions about how the format should be organized. upvoted / peace
Thank you @clumsysilverdad for your appreciation understanding and contemplation over the points here. I'm glad that you found it worthy enough to be upvoted. I'd like to send a small tip! post ed here for you. Thanks!
Hi @clumsysilverdad! @xyzashu is sending you 0.101 SBD tip and @tipU upvote
:)
Check out the newest post from @xyzashu: Meme Challenge # - 34 Entry # 1 and follow if you like the content :)You raised a valid point @xyzashu. I do agree with you. Steemit should be free from regionalism and closed community culture. Wrong tagging just to get upvote should be considered as a spam.
Thanks for raising this issue. 🌸 @OriginalWorks
Yes @chetanpadliya! Thanks a lot for echoing my thoughts! Here is a small tip! post ed for you for my pleasure.
The @OriginalWorks bot has determined this post by @xyzashu to be original material and upvoted it!
To call @OriginalWorks, simply reply to any post with @originalworks or !originalworks in your message!
To nominate this post for the daily RESTEEM contest, upvote this comment!
For more information, Click Here!
Hi @chetanpadliya! @xyzashu is sending you 0.101 SBD tip and @tipU upvote
:)
Check out the newest post from @xyzashu: Meme Challenge # - 34 Entry # 1 and follow if you like the content :)Some good points in there I was never thinking of to be honest - regional groups are here (mainly to help newbies from same language / region to get started) - indeed dangerous that can become secret and closed groups. I personally try to be open across the board but it is a human think to surround yourself with these people you might be linked to from language, culture or anything someone might have told you so. Some good points from you - we should all be different.
Can not comment on the specific india tag though.
Thank you for understanding me and visiting my blog! Here is a small tip! post ed for you. Do accept. Thanks again!
thanks a lot mate, very nice, checking your content out
Hi @uwelang! @xyzashu is sending you 0.101 SBD tip and @tipU upvote
:)
Check out the newest post from @xyzashu: Meme Challenge # - 34 Entry # 1 and follow if you like the content :)"Do you wanna create your relationships based on political borders?" - No, never. Dividing people can only bring violence, no matter on what basis people are divided, by continent, country, religion...
Congratulations! This post has been upvoted from the communal account, @minnowsupport, by xyzashu from the Minnow Support Project. It's a witness project run by aggroed, ausbitbank, teamsteem, theprophet0, someguy123, neoxian, followbtcnews/crimsonclad, and netuoso. The goal is to help Steemit grow by supporting Minnows and creating a social network. Please find us in the Peace, Abundance, and Liberty Network (PALnet) Discord Channel. It's a completely public and open space to all members of the Steemit community who voluntarily choose to be there.
This post has received a 0.78 % upvote from @drotto thanks to: @banjo.
Congratulations @xyzashu! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOP