The Deuce (Season 1) Review

in #television7 years ago

I'm aware this may be an unpopular opinion, but the television industry has gone the same banal way of Hollywood this decade. Sure, there's plenty of good shows out there, but there's nothing quite exciting, nothing innovative. Stuff like Fargo and Game of Thrones, while well done, are ultimately pure formula.

Nothing like the "Golden Era of US Television" through the 2000s. The Wire, The Sopranos, Six Feet Under, Deadwood, Battlestar Galactica, Arrested Development, Breaking Bad, Mad Men, and so many others. Not to mention some brilliant shows made outside of the US during this era.

Perhaps the only innovative show in this era is Rick and Morty, but this fall, we may have another.

The Deuce, a TV series about the prostitution industry and the rise of pornography, set in 1970s New York, with two James Francos. Of course, a lot of people dismissed that premise as something that'll inevitably turn sleazy. Of course, that's the challenge that George Pelecanos and David Simon took up.

Narrative fiction in general - whether it be books, movies/TV, or games - always ends up being a gross approximation of reality. This is a given, of course, but we have seen a trend in recent times towards what I would only call "two-dimensional". In trying to be realistic, the artifice shows even further, and ends up making a mockery of the issues it tries to deal with. Even the great shows ultimately end up being pastiches of themselves.

But The Deuce is no great show. There are no easy narrative conveniences, no formulae, no neatly pleasant packages designed to manipulate or gratify the audience.

The setting in The Deuce does not attempt to be beautiful. Neither does it attempt to be realistic. Instead, the 1970s New York is portrayed exactly as The Deuce - the show, not the actual 1970s Deuce locality - needs it to be. The costumes, the hair, the make-up, the locations - are all impeccable. To the point that the audience simply never questions or notices it.

That's why there's no other show like The Deuce on television or film. This is a show that is in such strong confidence and command of itself, that it simply does not even try and impress the audience. Stuff like Breaking Bad, Game of Thrones - great shows in their own right - constantly have a layer of artifice to them.

Not so with The Deuce, it is a show that understands the medium so well, and delicately straddles the very thin line between reality and fiction.

Continuing on my thoughts about the costumes etc, the same goes for the casting. It's all near perfect. We have seen James Franco and Maggie Gyllenhaal in big budget Hollywood blockbusters, but they seem born to play Vinnie and Frankie Martino; and Miss Merrell respectively. These are the roles and performances of a career; of a lifetime. The same holds true for every minor character, down to the extras you see for not more than minute.

So, back to what The Deuce is about - sex. There's a lot of it, of course, but it's all treated in an absolutely refreshing manner. If there were aliens - or Gods - they would look down upon humans as this absurd species which is driven entirely by sex. Every bit of crime, every bit of corruption, every virtuous act, every declaration of War, has ultimately one driving force - the act of copulation. The show portrays sex as just an act, where a penis penetrates a vagina several times. Something that most humans seem to be addicted to, for some reason or another. Of course, it need not be a penis and a vagina. It could be any combination thereof, or none at all.

I found that odd, at first. Surely, the folks in the 1970s weren't as liberated, considering the general prudishness of the population in this date. In my lifetime, there has been an enormous change in understanding of sexuality and various orientations and genders, but the people in The Deuce seemed to have much of it figured out way back then. As it turns out, after some research, it really was the case. Not exactly a depiction of history, but very much in the spirit of.

But of course, it isn't really about sex. It is about America, it is about freedom, capitalism, everything good about it, and everything flawed about it that ultimately corrupts. Mind you, it is not a political show at all, but the undertones are undeniable.

This would be a good place to recommend people easily offended by sexuality in its various forms to kindly stay away.

The characters in The Deuce come from a wide swath of backgrounds. Though the focal point is clearly the rise of the pornographic industry, there are people and stories of all types. The Deuce flirts so closely with the feeling of - "wow, I can feel this must have happened" - that often times as an audience, I question - "Why is this not happening?". Lo and behold, it does. The Deuce is a wide panorama of every nook and cranny of the human condition in this context, which somehow seems impossible to achieve in a mere 8 hours.

People do bad things, people do good things, but no one is judged upon. The best shows do have characters with shades of grey, but they often burdened with sanctimonious back-stories and justifications. Not in The Deuce. Every single character are just people, getting by.

A common wisdom goes like so - you make your characters likeable, or no one will like your work of fiction. Of course, this is The Deuce, and there's absolutely no attempt to make anyone likeable. People are complicated, and depending on who you are, you'll warm to like someone or the other - but rarely would it be the same person. That makes it all the more fun to discuss - as everyone has a different view of a different character.

And so it is, at every turn, there's utmost respect for the audience. The audience must pay attention and engage with the show, and by doing so it becomes an utterly spellbinding 8 hours of entertainment.

This is without doubt the finest Season 1 in television in this decade, and may even be one of the finest in television history. The porn industry is just getting started, and so is The Deuce. If it keeps firing at this rate in subsequent seasons, this might just end up being one of the finest pieces of fiction humankind has produced. Hyperbole, of course, and have rambled on for quite a while, but I don't care. I just had to write about it.

(All images from HBO.com)

Sort:  

Thank you for the review. I won't be watching. It doesn't seem to be my genre. I am more interested in shows like Lost, Good Wife, Halt & Catch Fire, etc. I am very impressed how well you articulate and present your message.
I agree with @trafalgar that television's golden age still continues. Especially with new players like Netflix, Amazon, other streaming companies joining this space and contributing to the production of tv shows.

A series sewn hand, made with care, an impeccable casting and very impressive sequences on the filmic plan. We take the time to pose the scenes, the dialogues are written by fairy fingers and we are quickly hooked by the atmosphere of New York in the early 70s populated by Pimp, prostitutes and poor women who pass a an artificial paradise for another or seek happiness from the oldest profession in the world!
James Franco is great, he plays two roles here and he is unrecognizable, it really feels like two brothers (a bit like Fincher had done so well with the actor Armie Hammer camping the Winkelvoss brothers in Social Network) and visually it's impeccable, you break your nose. The money spent for each episode is present on the screen, it shows!

Ah, yes, I recalled Armie Hammer too. But the James Franco doing the Martinos is even more subtle. You can never mistake the two characters, but it's hard to pinpoint exactly why. Whereas with Winklevi one was visibly and clearly more expressive and impulsive than the other.

This would be a good place to recommend people easily offended by sexuality in its various forms to kindly stay away.

I was expecting some NSFW stuff right here and scanned carefully down so as not to offend my precious little eyes. LOL

I missed McGyver and his Murdoc foe.

Fascinating review - thanks. It sometimes takes a while for innovative American shows to filter through to us in South Africa. Will look out for it. And hey, let's not knock porn...isn't that what financed the growth of the internet?

Unfortunately, HBO is terrible with international licensing. They have definitely improved, and I was able to watch it at a regional streaming service HBO has done a deal with. But that's not the case in most countries around the world. I guess your best bet would be waiting for the Bluray release or piracy.

That would be a bit of an exaggeration... The early internet was all about text and information. Porn really made the internet its own much later, once internet speeds had improved to the point of high quality pictures and video streaming. Certainly, porn is one of the most used activities on the internet even today. If I'm not mistaken, Pornhub is the second most viewed video streaming site after YouTube.

At least we get a good selection of HBO offerings through our (expensive) satellite TV service, which offers us a bouquet of 90% of stuff we don't want to watch but have to take in order to get the 10% we really want.

And on the porn thing, I was poking a bit of fun...however, it's certainly contributed to the growth of streaming capability, as you say. The early internet (not the one invented by Al Gore, the other one) was mostly used by academics and the military, wasn't it?


ezgif.com-resize.gif
The @OriginalWorks bot has determined this post by @liberosist to be original material and upvoted(2%) it!

To call @OriginalWorks, simply reply to any post with @originalworks or !originalworks in your message!

I like ur post...plz upvotes n comment me too

Thank you liberosist for this post. Clarified a few things for me. I saw this as it looked good then it got a bit too sleazy for me and I left my husband who liked it (he has good taste as it happens) to see it when he wanted to. Now I am curious to keep going and catch up. I like both main stars as they are tremendous actors, next time I won't make up my mind so fast, and am definitely not a prude! Your post is very timely sir!

Thanks to post

This will be high on my to do list.

good information bro, I hoop you upvoted me.

I should check this out
I think we're in the golden era of television this decade as well
breaking bad, rick and morty, stranger things, justified, the leftovers, the americans, are a few good ones that pop to mind and probably hold their own vs the sopranos, the wire, arrested development

hoping the deuce will deliver, i'm a big fan of good tv

I've just finished watching stranger things season 2, what a delight it was. Has all the charm of H.P Lovecraft and 80's theme mixed together. Now it is time for some porn!

haha hey good to see you still around moon :)
I'm back from my walkabout until i burn out again

Agreed on Breaking Bad and The Americans, though the former is more of a 2000s era show. Rick and Morty, of course. Stranger Things and Justified are good shows, but don't really measure up to the best from the previous decade for me. If you're a fan of The Wire or The Sopranos, you're going to be in for a treat with The Deuce!

fair enough, but I overall I think things are look good for tv
I named the shows I think were among the top, a shade below that there are at least 10 other series that are very impressive, GoT, the good wife, orange is the new black etc all among them

I too, miss the quality in television. I struggle though many of todays offerings and long for something better.

Agreed, it's been excellent, and it ended with a a masterpiece season finale.

click here.Congratulations @liberosist, this post is the eighth most rewarded post (based on pending payouts) in the last 12 hours written by a Superhero or Legend account holder (accounts hold greater than 100 Mega Vests). The total number of posts by Superhero and Legend account holders during this period was 23 and the total pending payments to posts in these categories was $1276.80. To see the full list of highest paid posts across all accounts categories,

If you do not wish to receive these messages in future, please reply stop to this comment.

james franco is an excellent artist. I love his movies. There is a depth to the story. Have a good day and a great weekend.

IMG-20171030-WA0082.jpg

i read about and watched the trailer and found this interesting and maybe will put it to the wishlist to watch. i have some problem with all this kind of TV series - the quality of a story and quality of the product as a movie. just a few weeks ago i finished to watch the 3d Fargo and everything what i tried - was a fall and failed try. (one of tries was a Luther - many people say that it's very close alternative to Fargo but really? )
in the same time i watch Better call Saul - and also waiting for the next season plus - True Detective season one - i was in such shock after watching, so i was unable even to think about some another try (season 2 was also unnecessary to spent time on)
i finished Breaking Bad twice and now really looking for some "alternative" for these 4 i wrote here..
can you advise me something please ? ?