It's funny! I have a post with a miniature orange tree from a while back ago where I talk a little about it. I was working full time and got a second job at the bonsai shop once I became interested in the art. I knew nothing (other than what Karate Kid and Mr. Miyagi could teach) about bonsai. I tried to tap the store owner for his wisdom and experience... but He was a salesman. So, I decided to work there. I figured if I got the job He would HAVE to teach me. I didn't learn as much as I would have liked but the experience was invaluable!
Technically your friend is right. Bonsai is grown in a container. This limitation on the root growth makes it miniaturize itself along with the pruning process. Ultimately, I think it's semantics. To me Bonsai is a miniature tree. So, your images, in my book, would be a "natural bonsai!" Trees don't grow naturally in containers or else they wouldn't be natural.
The whole point of the art of bonsai was to be able to domesticate a wild tree and bring it home for ornamental purposes... or to recreate a scene from nature and bring that home. The bonsai trees are supposed to remind the viewer of seeing a tree from the distance. The container represents the horizon and the smaller form of the tree is to give the illusion of distance. That is what I was taught. I am sure there is more complexity to it than that. Either way.... This Art mimics nature!
To find that in nature is, imho, much cooler than creating one of those from a container! I have been to Vancouver... but I didn't visit the island. That will be one thing to visit if I make it back out that way. I would love to swim out and actually touch that little tree. The reflection is amazing. I really like the angle it's growing at off the stump. I would imagine it's from the same tree... but it's possible a seed sprouted up there in the moss... but that is highly unlikely. Sorry for writing a novel... hahaha
Thrilled that you took the time to answer, thank you! I learned a lot from you there, glad I asked! Sitting in a kayak beside this tree I could just reach the top of the stump/bottom of the small tree with my hand. You can't see it in the photos, but there is a small hole in the wood where someone has placed some round stones which were painted red... No idea what the significance of that is, just thought it was cool :)
BTW, there is a campground on the lake where you can camp surrounded by large old-growth trees. It's amazing!
Sounds like a place that I NEED to visit! I absolutely love this post! This is an amazing experience that I am glad you shared! I look forward to seeing more of your posts! Steem On My Friend! =)