You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Metron Project - Introduction and Development Start

in #utopian-io • 7 years ago

Hi, I am @ms10398's supervisor, so I would like to clear up why your contribution was rejected

  • The first commit has 1,024,945 additions and 179,050 deletions, it's impossible to see if any of this was actually developed by you, or was just you adding October CMS files.
  • The second commit is the same, it seems like the only thing you changed from oc-bootstrap-v4-starter-kit is the text of the homepage (shown in your screenshot and linked here). This really isn't enough work to be accepted in the development category.
  • The third commit is you updating the README, which can't really be considered development.
  • The fourth commit is a license, which also can't be considered development.

If you disagree with my reasoning then feel free to contact me on Discord at Amos#4622 and we can discuss this further.

7 years ago in #utopian-io by
$0.00
    Reply 4
    Sort:  
  • Trending
    • [-]
     7 years ago  

    Hi Amos,

    Thank you for the message. I really appreciate your overview.

    I understand the points you made and it looks ok to me.

    There's one thing related to dev category I don't understand yet: doesn't Utopian supports an open source project start and project blueprint posts above any implementation effort?

    and I would also be interested to know, if and how much is the application architecture design work supported and accepted as contribution above the code implementation and if so what contribution category.

    Thank you

    $0.00
      Reply
      [-]
       7 years ago  

      Hi, sorry for the late reply, but here it is

      • Utopian rewards contributors for their work, so if a large part of a contribution is generated automatically for example (even though it's necessary for the project), then it probably won't be accepted.
      • I'm not sure what you mean by "application architecture design work" exactly, but for the development category we are really looking for something that has actually been implemented in the project.

      I'm not sure if I understood your questions correctly, so if I didn't, then don't hesitate to ask them again!

      [-]
       7 years ago  

      Hi - I'll try to keep it as short and straight to my points as possible

      1. Your first answer on this comment touches my point, Utopian rewards work. But what about a Project Blueprint or Project Overview with an Analysis of a Problem and The Reasons of The Project. Does utopian support the writing work related to it? I'll make an example related to this question, does a post like this have any chance currently to be supported by Utopian vote for any of the categories?

      2. by "application architecture design work" I mean: Software Architecture Models as UML diagrams for example. Is this kind of work currently supported?

      Thank you
      Michael

      $0.00
        Reply
        [-]
         7 years ago  

        Hi again, I'll try my best to answer your questions

        • This might be suited to the blog category, but I have no experience moderating that category so you are better off asking someone like @espoem or @roj about this.
        • This isn't currently supported (in the development category at least, not sure about others, but don't think it is).

        If you have any other questions in the future it would probably be better if you contacted me on Discord at Amos#4622.