Ah see well from the perspective of the DAO hacker and ETC, no theft occurred.
The rules of the contract were not broken.
The reason for rewriting the blockchain is irrelevant.
All that matters is if the community has the consensus to do it.
Of course, your points are valid, and we are on the same side. I would not vote to fork @ned's stake away. These arguments obviously make consensus harder to achieve.
At the same time I also respect consensus. I won't be a sore loser if my side doesn't win. Or maybe I will and the chain will fork. Depends on how big both communities are and how worth it the fork would be.