You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: HF Idea / Proposal: Witness Disapproval Feature

in #witness6 years ago

We are talking about an attack on the top 20/30 witnesses, the rest does not matter much for this attack. So basically if they seize 10 and downvote the other 20 they can control more.

Sort:  

hmm... but downvoting 20 others with enough power would then allow another group of 20 to rise to the top? Or am I completely misunderstanding?

Like I said, not yet fleshed out :) Maybe others can chime in to explore if this can be used as an attack

In reality, such an attack would not be likely to be carried out by a government or other large group because they already have enough money to just buy their way into the top 20 anyway ;)
However, the idea of downvoting accounts while also being able to upvote accounts would certainly be a less noticeable way to takeover the system, since the downvoting and witness account running could be spread over numerous accounts, making it hard to track and co-relate the actions to one another.

I do think there is some merit to reducing the number of witness votes though, maybe 9 is a good idea, so that the same SP cannot be used to affect more than 50% of the witnesses.