Hold up... I guess this is all my fault, LOL.
bunny fluff had 2 daggers, an ingot, and a gem before I started Setzer's crazy manuevering here. I took one of the daggers and the gem off the fluffster's hands. So bunny fluff had a dagger and an ingot left, good for +2 to their roll.
@what-is-life rolled a 2, which means bunny fluff's total was 4 and Gobbo was beaten. bunny fluff is still alive with 1 life but needs to loot this Gobbo with the !pickpocket command before continuing.